Jon White on the Best Horses of the last 50 years...

[slotdirt]

Hasn't J. White been sort of discredited in so far as his opinion on the relatively ability of horses goes after the 2009 Triple Crown series?

[johnny pinwheel]

Originally Posted by slotdirt

Hasn't J. White been sort of discredited in so far as his opinion on the relatively ability of horses goes after the 2009 Triple Crown series?

who believes in any of this dribble anyway? some moron prints up one these lists and its supposed to be the holy grail of racing? its like some of these threads. "what was the best 5 defeats of male horses by a feamle since 2005" or some such crap. does it really matter? how does anyone know? were they out there running in the field? who crowns these so called "experts " with the authority to claim such crap? and furthurmore, who are the fools that read this stuff and buy into it? i hope they bet horses.....lol. #7 or #8 on the list is better than #4....even though #8 raced 45 year ago and died about 35 years ago. instead of handicapping and winning some money...i think i'll analyze this and waste my time, telling folks why #5 is better than #6...then people wonder why this guy sucks.....its hilarious to read and see people argue...but it makes no sense whatsoever!

[AeWingnut]

How can Zenyatta make the list while Cigar does not?
or for that matter Curlin?

Curlin gets to race on dirt he wins the BC Classic
Zenyatta doesn't race on plastic and she wins the Apple Blossum