olympic judging

[Cannon Shell]

Admittedly I know very little about many of these "sports" but watching the ones that are judged it is like no one else knows either. There have been some awful calls and refs in boxing, so bad that it can be almost unwatchable since the points are seemingly given out randomly. Today they were showing some of the bad calls and it was almost comical how many mistakes are made. The FIBA refs in basketball are very inconsistent but they seem like they are bad on both sides of the ball. As for the gymnastics and diving, outside of the really bad ones they all pretty much look the same but the scores seem to be based upon reputation and country as much as anything.

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Admittedly I know very little about many of these "sports" but watching the ones that are judged it is like no one else knows either. There have been some awful calls and refs in boxing, so bad that it can be almost unwatchable since the points are seemingly given out randomly. Today they were showing some of the bad calls and it was almost comical how many mistakes are made. The FIBA refs in basketball are very inconsistent but they seem like they are bad on both sides of the ball. As for the gymnastics and diving, outside of the really bad ones they all pretty much look the same but the scores seem to be based upon reputation and country as much as anything.

The kid from Ireland that lost to the Chinese boxer was
an absolute joke. This boxing scoring system is a complete mystery.

The basketball... at least we knew how bad it could get.

The sports that require judges to score a performance
are impossible for me to care about who wins a medal.
I just watch for the athleticism, in the gymnastics anyway.

The ribbon flinging and hoop tossing... Bring on Chess instead.

[hi_im_god]

Originally Posted by pgardn

The kid from Ireland that lost to the Chinese boxer was
an absolute joke. This boxing scoring system is a complete mystery.

The basketball... at least we knew how bad it could get.

The sports that require judges to score a performance
are impossible for me to care about who wins a medal.
I just watch for the athleticism, in the gymnastics anyway.

The ribbon flinging and hoop tossing... Bring on Chess instead.

shock.

the physics guy likes accurate measurement.

i'd have pegged you as one where the flawed opinion of an alleged expert would matter.

[Cannon Shell]

Bowling
Madden 09
MMA
pool
poker
skateboarding

are all needed to make the olympics legit

Originally Posted by hi_im_god

shock.

the physics guy likes accurate measurement.

i'd have pegged you as one where the flawed opinion of an alleged expert would matter.

ouch ka bibbles.

The saber has laid me to rest.

[Cannon Shell]

There is a lot of hugging at the olympics...some of it makes me very uncomfortable...

[mclem0822]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Admittedly I know very little about many of these "sports" but watching the ones that are judged it is like no one else knows either. There have been some awful calls and refs in boxing, so bad that it can be almost unwatchable since the points are seemingly given out randomly. Today they were showing some of the bad calls and it was almost comical how many mistakes are made. The FIBA refs in basketball are very inconsistent but they seem like they are bad on both sides of the ball. As for the gymnastics and diving, outside of the really bad ones they all pretty much look the same but the scores seem to be based upon reputation and country as much as anything.

Chuck, I totally agree the boxing score is laughable! To expect these judges to push a freakin button after every punch that lands, is an impossible assignment in my opinion! They need to throw out this stupid instant scoring system, and just judge this round by round, sure you wanna make each round's scoring known after each round fine, I got no problem with that. But they need to revamp this, and hopefully they will by 2012!

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

There is a lot of hugging at the olympics...some of it makes me very uncomfortable...

Ahhhh.
The rugged hug in water polo.

They pull at swimming suits and those cool little astronaut hats also.
Bloody hugs.

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by mclem0822

Chuck, I totally agree the boxing score is laughable! To expect these judges to push a freakin button after every punch that lands, is an impossible assignment in my opinion! They need to throw out this stupid instant scoring system, and just judge this round by round, sure you wanna make each round's scoring known after each round fine, I got no problem with that. But they need to revamp this, and hopefully they will by 2012!

Yeah it sucks. Atlas said it best when he said i hope they are just incompetent, not corrupt. take the freakin head gear off, make it six, three minute rounds, have a qualifier the week or 2 before to get rid of the riff-raff and have it judged. Have each judge make notes each round explaining why they gave each round to the fighter. If a judge has consistently bad scores get rid of him before the medal rounds

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by pgardn

Ahhhh.
The rugged hug in water polo.

They pull at swimming suits and those cool little astronaut hats also.
Bloody hugs.

too much hugging in mens volleyball too

[mclem0822]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Yeah it sucks. Atlas said it best when he said i hope they are just incompetent, not corrupt. take the freakin head gear off, make it six, three minute rounds, have a qualifier the week or 2 before to get rid of the riff-raff and have it judged. Have each judge make notes each round explaining why they gave each round to the fighter. If a judge has consistently bad scores get rid of him before the medal rounds

Great idea! Problem is it may make too much sense for the IOC to ever consider giving it a try!

[GPK]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

too much hugging in mens volleyball too

and not enough hugging in women's.....especially the beach volleyball

[docicu3]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Bowling
Madden 09
MMA
pool
poker
skateboarding

are all needed to make the olympics legit

you left out jousting ....on horseback of course......

...and perhaps a version of those bike races on crack where points are awarded for picking off fallen competition....

[ddthetide]

ALL the judging sports should be banned from the olympics! boxing and gymnastics are 2 of the worst jokes for the longest time. oh and the x-game "sports" should be gone too.

[ddthetide]

this is the first i've watched any of the boxing. what a FREAKING JOKE!!
the IOC should make them clean this mess up or get rid of it period.

[Mortimer]

Fellers...let's admit it.



People have laughed at me because I always tell them cheating goes on through out the sporty world.

Whether it's players ,refs,judges,commissioners,owners....and what have you.



Even horseys cheat.






Cheating is an innate trait among the solids.



Liquids and gases have never been caught cheating.

















Check that.











There are some gases here who I suspect cheat.

[GPK]

Originally Posted by Mortimer

Fellers...let's admit it.



People have laughed at me because I always tell them cheating goes on through out the sporty world.

Whether it's players ,refs,judges,commissioners,owners....and what have you.
Even horseys cheat.
Cheating is an innate trait among the solids.
Liquids and gases have never been caught cheating.
Check that.
there are some gases here who I suspect cheat.

^^ chief lobbyists for Youngstown, OH 2016