Domo Arigato & Sayonara! I'll Have Another to Japan..

Truly sad that we can not keep a horse of this caliber in the States for breeding. Best of luck IHA as you fly off to your new home....

Scat

[Kasept]

Originally Posted by scat daddy

Truly sad that we can not keep a horse of this caliber in the States for breeding. Best of luck IHA as you fly off to your new home....

Scat

Please.. 'truly sad'? As explained here by many and elsewhere by anyone in bloodstock, there's no market for him here. NONE. If you want a horse of his caliber you can breed to Flower Alley and get one. Or Distorted Humor if you want one the caliber of Flower Alley and can afford it. Or go to OBS and try to craft one for $25k-$40.

[Soaring Softly]

Here's an interesting piece from Lenny Shulman at Bloodhorse on the lack of an American market for I'll Have Another, and how the situation eerily parallels that of Sunday Silence.

http://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-raci...sunday-silence

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by Soaring Softly

Here's an interesting piece from Lenny Shulman at Bloodhorse on the lack of an American market for I'll Have Another, and how the situation eerily parallels that of Sunday Silence.

http://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-raci...sunday-silence

The only things similar between the two are the KD/Preakness wins and the inability to bring high prices as unraced horses and stud prospects.

Sunday Silence was much better a runner. Sunday Silence had a much better sire. Sunday Silence raced into his four year old season. Sunday Silence's dam was a nice stakes winning mare. Want more?

[slotdirt]

Quite literally the only similarity is what I'll have Another and Sunday Silence did on the first Saturday in May and three weeks later.

[Merlinsky]

Originally Posted by Kasept

Please.. 'truly sad'? As explained here by many and elsewhere by anyone in bloodstock, there's no market for him here. NONE. If you want a horse of his caliber you can breed to Flower Alley and get one. Or Distorted Humor if you want one the caliber of Flower Alley and can afford it. Or go to OBS and try to craft one for $25k-$40.

Yeah, although it's sad to see him go, there really isn't a market, it's just a no brainer for Mr. Reddam, and the interest of the Japanese in Flower Alley's family put that writing on the wall awhile back. He'll arguably have a better chance of success there than here, not having to compete with his sire and grandsire. If someone wants his particular genes badly enough, he's not behind an iron curtain. You could get to him if you had to. Import a foal in utero or something. I doubt anybody's gonna unless he ended up being the next Sunday Silence. I'm just saying you could.

Isn't there a possibility that he could've won the Triple Crown, gotten injured before the Travers instead, and still ended up in Japan? Is the cache of being the TC winner really enough to keep him here?

His female family is what it is. The Distorted Humor and Flower Alley situations would still affect his value in the US market. Case Clay speculated about what a TC winner would be worth, and I'm not sure that the number Reddam got offered for a dual Classic winning IHA jumps that much post-Belmont win vs. what the Japanese would be willing to offer. Would IHA need a TC win and a strong rest of his 3yo season to earn his spot here? Does he have to race at 4? I got the impression that a 4yo career was in the cards and wondered if that wasn't to try to improve the offer they'd get from US farms. Didn't work for Sunday Silence.

Originally Posted by Kasept

Please.. 'truly sad'? As explained here by many and elsewhere by anyone in bloodstock, there's no market for him here. NONE. If you want a horse of his caliber you can breed to Flower Alley and get one. Or Distorted Humor if you want one the caliber of Flower Alley and can afford it. Or go to OBS and try to craft one for $25k-$40.

Imma Down Hoss....your looking at this totally different than me. I am just stating that it is SAD for this to happen. I am not looking to breed to anything puhlleezz.. just not a fan of the situation at hand. Someone needs a vacation...


Scat

[Kasept]

Originally Posted by scat daddy

Imma Down Hoss....your looking at this totally different than me. I am just stating that it is SAD for this to happen. I am not looking to breed to anything puhlleezz.. just not a fan of the situation at hand. Someone needs a vacation...


Scat

[AlreadyHome]

Originally Posted by Kasept

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by scat daddy

Truly sad that we can not keep a horse of this caliber in the States for breeding. Best of luck IHA as you fly off to your new home....

Scat

that's part of the problem, we already have horses of his caliber in the states for breeding.

[Linny]

Though he doesn't have a glamorous stallion's pedigree, he hails from a good sireline and is bred to route yet won his debut at 5 1/2 early in his 2yo year. I like route bred horses that show speed.

I do wonder what (if any) interest there would have been had IHA won the TC. It's not the like Belmont is the kind of race that gets breeders on the phone to bloodstock agents.

[parsixfarms]

Originally Posted by Linny

It's not the like Belmont is the kind of race that gets breeders on the phone to bloodstock agents.

For as much as a lot of people like to knock the Belmont as being antiquated, it has a much better record of producing sires than the Derby does. In the last twenty years, the roster of Belmont winners who became useful sires includes A. P. Indy, Lemon Drop Kid, Thunder Gulch, Empire Maker, Victory Gallop, Touch Gold, Afleet Alex, Birdstone, and Point Given. The "best" Derby-winning sire from the same time period would likely be Thunder Gulch. The best of the rest would be Street Sense, Smarty Jones, FuPeg, and Real Quiet.

[freddymo]

Originally Posted by parsixfarms

For as much as a lot of people like to knock the Belmont as being antiquated, it has a much better record of producing sires than the Derby does. In the last twenty years, the roster of Belmont winners who became useful sires includes A. P. Indy, Lemon Drop Kid, Thunder Gulch, Empire Maker, Victory Gallop, Touch Gold, Afleet Alex, Birdstone, and Point Given. The "best" Derby-winning sire from the same time period would likely be Thunder Gulch. The best of the rest would be Street Sense, Smarty Jones, FuPeg, and Real Quiet.

Point Given thru frogs
Victory Gallop Really?
Thunder friggin Gulch?
Afleet Alex is hardily the cats meow
Birdstone ........."Elizabeth I am coming"
Touch Gold wow

This is a list of train wrecks

[AlreadyHome]

Please go on and explain why freddymo

"This is a list of train wrecks"


numbers don't lie

[Merlinsky]

Speaking of Birdstone, for those who like to follow the select sales, the yearlings born of the broodmare bump following the success of his first crop at age 3 (including Mine That Bird's Kentucky Derby and Summer Bird's Belmont/Travers/JCGC/3yo Eclipse) are coming up this year. Probably won't do that well since freddy's convinced he's a bum. I bet the auctioneer will even announce it from the podium. "Ladies and gentleman, an addition to the catalog...The Freddymo Seal of Sire Disapproval is missing from the page of Hip #..."

Please go on and explain why.

Scat

[PatCummings]

Safe to say that Steve Haskin agrees with Scat Daddy and some others in an interesting discussion on today's show.