giants

[gales0678]

[quote=Antitrust32]do you need to ask? Its Andy Reid.. he just does that ****. Most overrated coach out there.

Donovan coulnd hit the broad side of a barn either.

We outplayed Dallas and came away with a L Blame 3 factors.. Andy Reid sucks, Donovan sucks ( I would bet $1000 we would have won that game with Kolb.. and I dont care how much crap I get for saying that) and stupid penalties the whole game.

And the refs suck.. it was obvious McNabb got that 1st down on the 4th and inches... the refs should have manned up and reversed the call on the challenge.. the ball should have been placed at least 8 or 9 inches further than it was.. disgrace.[/QUOTE]

the call couldn't be overturned because the replay officals could not see all of donovan's body , thus there was not eneough conclusive evidence to change the spot
they didn't change the spot on the catch with d jax when reid challenged and it looked like the ball should have been placed further back
could you tell me where his left elbow was in any of the replays?

after all that reid kicking a fg with no timeouts was just plain stupid

[Antitrust32]

Originally Posted by gales0678

[

the call couldn't be overturned because the replay officals could not see all of donovan's body , thus there was not eneough conclusive evidence to change the spot
they didn't change the spot on the catch with d jax when reid challenged and it looked like the ball should have been placed further back
could you tell me where his left elbow was in any of the replays?

after all that reid kicking a fg with no timeouts was just plain stupid

one elbow was in the air and one was on the cowgirls player. it was a bad call by the refs but not the sole reason we lost. McReid and McChoke are the reasons we lost. and bad penalties which also falls on Reid.

Eagles are 1-8-1 in the last 10 games decided by 6 points or less.. and some of you actually think McChoke is a top quality QB. top QB's have much greater records in close games.. McNabb is absolutely horrible in his career in that stat.

[gales0678]

Originally Posted by Antitrust32

one elbow was in the air and one was on the cowgirls player. it was a bad call by the refs but not the sole reason we lost. McReid and McChoke are the reasons we lost. and bad penalties which also falls on Reid.

Eagles are 1-8-1 in the last 10 games decided by 6 points or less.. and some of you actually think McChoke is a top quality QB. top QB's have much greater records in close games.. McNabb is absolutely horrible in his career in that stat.

rush limbaugh agrees

you can't see his left elbow in the replay , no one knows for certanty where it was so you can't overturn

[Antitrust32]

Originally Posted by gales0678

rush limbaugh agrees

you can't see his left elbow in the replay , no one knows for certanty where it was so you can't overturn

i kinda agree that its hard to overturn a spot.. but it was a real bad spot from the get-go.

As soon as they ran the play I thought for sure first down.. couldnt believe where the dude was running out.. back by McChoke's feet.