Football Hall of Fame- Yes or No

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by philcski

Because of the possibility of career ending injuries at any point, can look at it either as "if their career ended tomorrow" or "projected to a reasonable length career"

QB's
Brett Favre Yes
Tom Brady Yes
Peyton Manning Yes
Drew Brees no but if he keeps his current pace for a few more years and the Saints can have some playoff success then yes
Kurt Warnerno but if he plays full seasons and makes the playoffs for a couple years he may be a yes
Donovan McNabbassuming he lays at same level for 3 -4 years yes
Ben Rothlisbergerno still 5 good years away
Carson Palmerno hasnt done enough but at current production rate in 5 years is in

RB's * suprising lack of quantity here, add names as you feel fit
LaDanian Tomlinson yes
Adrian Petersonobviously hasnt played enough but at current production levels for 4 or 5 more years he is an easy yes
Jamal Lewis after first 3 years was heading there but injuries hurt. Is 21st all time in rushing and 14th in rush yards per game but no for me


WR's/TE's
Randy Mossyes
Hines Wardnot yet but getting close
Steve Smith (CAR of course)no
Wes Welkerno
Larry Fitzgeraldnot yet but in 3-4 years will be close
Anquan Boldinno still aways away
Chad "Ochocinco"no and is already 31
Reggie Waynesame as above and is 32
Terrell Owensyes
Andre Johnson4/5 more years
Donald Driverno and is old
Torry Holtyes
TJ Houshmanzadehno
Tony Gonzalezunanimous pick
Antonio Gatesneeds a couple more years