Easy Goer Was Better than Sunday Silence

[smartbid09]

Originally Posted by HomerS

it was settled on the track unlike so many of these discussions. Sunday Silence was better. He won three of four times what am I missing? If Easy Goer was better why didnt he win three times?

One win.

How can he be considered better?


To me this is one of easiest debates to have

Homer if you read what I wrote you would see that I don't think that Sunday Silence's wins make him the better horse. I can't make you read what I wrote I really challenge that argument. I respect and value your opinion and can tell you believe SS was better but I really don't think that SS was better because he was the victor three of the 4 times they met. You say when Easy Goer met a real challenge he was exposed as not so good but Easy Goer - read his bullets above - was not just winning he was setting track records! He was not just beating horses he was beating horses in times that set track records