Hall of Fame? Yes or No

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by King Glorious

Ichiro and Guerrero are the only two I'd vote in.

One reason why it's hard to judge by number of times they won an MVP or finished high in the voting is 1999.

Jones
45-110 .319 avg, .441 obp, .633 slg, 359 total bases, 41 doubles, 116 runs, 181 hits

Guerrero
42-131 .316 avg, .378 obp, .600 slg, 366 total bases, 37 doubles, 102 runs, 193 hits

Jones won the MVP. Guerrero finished 11th.

If Guerrero played for the Braves he would have won three or 4 MVP's