If Nashoba wins BC, can she be HOY??

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Sightseek

I think she definitely would deserve to be a Nominee, even moreso than Rags to Riches who has been mentioned as being deservant.

The voting for the 3 year old Eclipse could be very interesting with Curlin having defeated Street Sense and an older horse in Lawyer Ron (who unless the unlikely happens and Brass Hat wins the Classic has Older Male pretty much locked up), Street Sense with a solid season and scintillating Derby victory and Hard Spun who has a good of a chance as any of these in the Classic.

Does Rags to Riches loose the 3 Year Old Filly Eclipse?

If Lear's Princess or Lady Joanne win the Distaff, my vote if I were given one, would lean to either of them.

i have a hard time believing rags will lose top 3 yo filly. many will think she only lost to lear's princess due to the injury that put an end to her year, and she's the only filly to take on the colts and win--and in the belmont to boot--while beating curlin, who now can lay claim to taking on and beating older horses, something the other 3 yo's can't say as yet.

edit~i forgot tiago, poor thing...