Vick

Originally Posted by Bababooyee

I guess that depends on how loosely you define "led". Being a QB of a Super Bowl team doesn't mean you have led anything. Do you recall how awful he was in the playoffs last year? Do you recall how awful he was in the Super Bowl? He sucked.

Besides, winning a Super Bowl doesn't always mean you are a great QB or even very good (eg Rypien, Dilfer, etc.). He gets hype because (a) he is young and (b) he is a Steeler, not because of how he has played (especially in the playoffs or Super Bowl).

He might not be 100% this year, I'll give you that. But his awful streak started well before the motorcycle crash and everything else since then.

Not that I am a fan of Vick, either. Unjustified hype in any case is annoying. But Vick is definitely playing well and deserves some kudos for his play this year.

Vick deserves criticism for his play before the Steelers game. Look at the numbers. Horrible.