What An Allowance Race!!

[cmorioles]

Originally Posted by parsixfarms

But subsequent races have pretty much exposed Dreaming of Julia's performance in the Gulfstream Park Oaks as yet the latest in a long line of performances from Pletcher trainees in South Florida (with its out-dated testing protocols, if you can call them testing protocols) that are not duplicated elsewhere.

I'm a huge fan of Midnight Lucky but putting her, Close Hatches or Dreaming of Julia ahead of Beholder in the divisional rankings when Beholder has two Grade I wins, and a "maybe best" second in the Oaks (beating each of those three fillies) to her resume is pretty silly.

I know she has been exposed, but at the time nobody was complaining that Beholder should be rated ahead of her. We've all seen Triple Crown race winners passed later in the year by other horses that couldn't touch them in April. That is all I'm saying. Maybe he thinks Close Hatches has improved a lot and Beholder has not. I really don't know.

I'm certainly not defending his rankings as they've been off base many times over the years. What are they even supposed to represent?