Definition of Great Horse

[ateamstupid]

Originally Posted by Pillow Pants

Rock Shock Jayhawk?

Something wrong?

[ceejay]

Ghostzapper: G1 wins at 6.5,8,9,10 f. Not "slew-worthy" but still great in my book.

[hoovesupsideyourhead]

Originally Posted by ceejay

Ghostzapper: G1 wins at 6.5,8,9,10 f. Not "slew-worthy" but still great in my book.

imo the iron horses of the past are never coming back sec.and man o war duels are just a dream in todays landscape ..i think we give credit where do..gz was a great horse..re wrote the speed figures..tiznow great invasor has proven hes worthy..or at least belongs..great by my standerds is more in the here and now..the past is the past ..from what i can see from some of the mares in foal we should have a few superstars in afew years...

[Charismatic1]

I put memorable horses into two categories: great careers and great performances. Often, I look at the comparison between the first and second place horses in the '02 2000 Guineas. Many on here will say that Hawk Wing was vastly more talented than The Rock. I disagree, but I can accept that view. This view is likely coined by the couple of absolutely freakish performances Hawk Wing dished out. However, he only had one win at 3 and one at 4. The Rock, on the other hand, was a machine. He ran as well as he had to and always got the job done - save for one dreary Chicago day. So, while Hawk Wing may have had the cooler highlight film, Rock of Gibralter clearly had the greater career (albeit, too short in its own right). Personally, I tend to go with great careers over one or two freaky performances.

-Ryan

[hoovesupsideyourhead]

Originally Posted by Charismatic1

I put memorable horses into two categories: great careers and great performances. Often, I look at the comparison between the first and second place horses in the '02 2000 Guineas. Many on here will say that Hawk Wing was vastly more talented than The Rock. I disagree, but I can accept that view. This view is likely coined by the couple of absolutely freakish performances Hawk Wing dished out. However, he only had one win at 3 and one at 4. The Rock, on the other hand, was a machine. He ran as well as he had to and always got the job done - save for one dreary Chicago day. So, while Hawk Wing may have had the cooler highlight film, Rock of Gibralter clearly had the greater career (albeit, too short in its own right). Personally, I tend to go with great careers over one or two freaky performances.

-Ryan

very true..agreed ..my fav chesterhouse also ran well and in my opinion is a good duel perp sire.. to bad hes gone..

[Danzig]

again, see finley.
yes, he said, GZ was great. and as he said, great just isn't so great anymore.

there are greats. and then there are modern era greats. not everything improves with time.