Are the Patriots better without Randy Moss?

[dalakhani]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

I know i will get blasted but I always thought Montana was a bit overrated. Great player and top 5 QB but he played for Bill Walsh and had jerry Rice. I dont think Joe Montana is in the top 10 if he played for a different team. People forget but he wasnt very durable towards the end of his SF career and Young (who also was always hurt) came in and pretty much picked up where Montana left off.

Elway made way too many mistakes and threw way too many bad balls to be considered better than Brady or Manning IMO.

People forget that Montana won two without rice. Rules were different then and a defensive back actually had a chance. For my money, the guy playing corner for the jets right now is the best ever at that spot.

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by dalakhani

For my money, the guy playing corner for the jets right now is the best ever at that spot.

I have a real hard time saying that a guy with 2 good seasons is the best ever.

[Bigsmc]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

I have a real hard time saying that a guy with 2 good seasons is the best ever.

It's the same with any sport, including horse racing, people are in such a rush to crown the latest phenom as the best ever.