Vikings Love in Vegas

[gales0678]

Originally Posted by dalakhani

Is he top 5 now? 21 tds 3 picks and his team is 9-1. Is he a top 5 QB?

no

i would take

manning
brady
brees
warner
schaub

he has a better running attack then all of the above teams

[dalakhani]

Originally Posted by gales0678

no

i would take

manning
brady
brees
warner
schaub

he has a better running attack then all of the above teams

Are you kidding? Favre is making Sidney Rice into a star. Schaub has Andre Johnson and Warner has the best receiver combo in the game. Regardless of this, Favre still has better numbers.

[gales0678]

Originally Posted by dalakhani

Are you kidding? Favre is making Sidney Rice into a star. Schaub has Andre Johnson and Warner has the best receiver combo in the game. Regardless of this, Favre still has better numbers.

hou - has to use 3 backs

ari - hightower/wells

if AP goes down and Favre puts up the #'s then he becomes a top 5 , until then he is a good qb with one of the 2 best rb's in football

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by gales0678

hou - has to use 3 backs

ari - hightower/wells

if AP goes down and Favre puts up the #'s then he becomes a top 5 , until then he is a good qb with one of the 2 best rb's in football

Your really far off on this one and I dont like Farve....

[gales0678]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

Your really far off on this one and I dont like Farve....

kurt warner or schaub wouldn't be 9-1 with this team???

[dalakhani]

Originally Posted by gales0678

kurt warner or schaub wouldn't be 9-1 with this team???

When has Schaub ever been 9-1 with ANY team? LOL

The question should be, what would zona and Houston be with Favre at the helm.

[gales0678]

Originally Posted by dalakhani

When has Schaub ever been 9-1 with ANY team? LOL

The question should be, what would zona and Houston be with Favre at the helm.

don't forget about rivers

[NTamm1215]

Schaub would have a hard time being 9-1 with the 2007 Patriots because the guy has no b.alls in the clutch. He completely botched two throws in the final 4 offensive plays of their loss at Arizona earlier this year. He threw a crucial interception at Indy in a game that the Texans were largely in control of during the 2nd half. He was a no show in the season opener when his #1 target was shut down.

The idea that anyone would take Schaub over Favre right now, or ever, is crazy and I have never been a Favre fan.

NT

[gales0678]

Originally Posted by dalakhani

When has Schaub ever been 9-1 with ANY team? LOL

The question should be, what would zona and Houston be with Favre at the helm.

zona's would have the same record with favre as they do with warner

maybe houston would have 1 more win with favre

Originally Posted by gales0678

kurt warner or schaub wouldn't be 9-1 with this team???

Hell no.

[gales0678]

Originally Posted by Coach Pants

Hell no.

tell me the game they would have lost , outside of sf , at worst they are 8-2

7 of 10 games of been in the dome for favre, he stunk last year in the winds at the meadowlands


cutler buried him in the denver game

[dalakhani]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

Your really far off on this one and I dont like Farve....

Thats the funny thing Pg. I was never a huge fan either. But God...you have to love what the old guy is doing!

[dalakhani]

Originally Posted by gales0678

hou - has to use 3 backs

ari - hightower/wells

if AP goes down and Favre puts up the #'s then he becomes a top 5 , until then he is a good qb with one of the 2 best rb's in football

LOL. Okay. This thread is hilarious. The guy has thrown 21 tds with 3 picks. His best receiver is Sidney Rice. Sidney ****ing Rice.

I dont care if they brought a walter payton in his prime clone on to the field as his tb. He is playing GREAT football.

At this point, he is having arguably one of the top five seasons of any qb around. He is number one in td/int ratio and number one in qb rating. He is top 10 in almost every other meaningful stat and his team is 9-1.