Who Is Horse Of The Year?

[kgar311]

Originally Posted by letswastemoney

-It's questionable how good MTB is on synthetics
-Her G1 dirt win was last year. It doesn't count towards a HOY argument
-14 for 14 again does not count. What matters is what she did THIS year compared to RA

-But if you are going to compare wins on completely different surfaces, RA beat Summer Bird by 6 or 7. Zenyatta, not so much.

Also MTB was at his peak when RA faced him, Zen caught the shell of that horse.
These are just the arguments that people on Bloodhorse are making for Zenyatta, they go on and on with these same nonsense arguments its absolutely nauseating to read.
The best one I read over there was that Zen was NEVER headed