She's Done

[Gander]

I'm for Rachel but I can see arguments for both. Zenyatta won this race a lot more easier than the margin of victory demonstrates, and this group was better than any group rachel beat, I dont care what surface it was run on.
But in Rachel's defense, she beat better horses more often, travelled to 6? race tracks to do it. Sure she aniliated a couple of very weak fields in the KY Oaks and the Moothe Goose, but Zenyatta beat weak fields every time she ran (except the BC Classic). I'm not sold on Life is Sweet's win elevating the field's Zenyatta beat all year either.

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Gander

I'm for Rachel but I can see arguments for both. Zenyatta won this race a lot more easier than the margin of victory demonstrates, and this group was better than any group rachel beat, I dont care what surface it was run on.
But in Rachel's defense, she beat better horses more often, travelled to 6? race tracks to do it. Sure she aniliated a couple of very weak fields in the KY Oaks and the Moothe Goose, but Zenyatta beat weak fields every time she ran (except the BC Classic). I'm not sold on Life is Sweet's win elevating the field's Zenyatta beat all year either.

oaklawn
fairgrounds
churchill
pimlico
belmont
saratoga
monmouth

i think that's all the ones she raced on.

head to head you have rachel with almost twice as many races, with a record setter in the martha washington, a record margin in the oaks..three victories over males vs zenyatta with one. i think rachel got 5 gr 1's this year-how many did zenyatta get?
zenyatta's performance saturday was incredible-but i don't know that it was moreso than some of rachel's best.

[Gander]

Originally Posted by Danzig

oaklawn
fairgrounds
churchill
pimlico
belmont
saratoga
monmouth

i think that's all the ones she raced on.

head to head you have rachel with almost twice as many races, with a record setter in the martha washington, a record margin in the oaks..three victories over males vs zenyatta with one. i think rachel got 5 gr 1's this year-how many did zenyatta get?
zenyatta's performance saturday was incredible-but i don't know that it was moreso than some of rachel's best.

Grade 1's are kind of irrelevant when it comes to these two phenoms. They practically write Grade 1's just for these two.

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Gander

Grade 1's are kind of irrelevant when it comes to these two phenoms. They practically write Grade 1's just for these two.

i'm just mentioning that for hoy voting purposes. it's a shame zenyatta is most likely thru, she may have 'done enough'. but i'd like to see her get the win streak record.

[CSC]

Originally Posted by Danzig

oaklawn
fairgrounds
churchill
pimlico
belmont
saratoga
monmouth

i think that's all the ones she raced on.

head to head you have rachel with almost twice as many races, with a record setter in the martha washington, a record margin in the oaks..three victories over males vs zenyatta with one. i think rachel got 5 gr 1's this year-how many did zenyatta get?
zenyatta's performance saturday was incredible-but i don't know that it was moreso than some of rachel's best.

If they both meet in the Classic next year at CD, and if Zenyatta can maintain her form at age 6, I think people will realize just who the better filly truly is and was.

[Gander]

Originally Posted by CSC

If they both meet in the Classic next year at CD, if Zenyatta can maintain her form, I think people will realize just who the better filly truly is and was.

Thats a might big IF but hope it happens.
I'd say there is a way greater chance you'll never see either run in another race again.

[NTamm1215]

Originally Posted by CSC

If they both meet in the Classic next year at CD, and if Zenyatta can maintain her form at age 6, I think people will realize just who the better filly truly is and was.

Do you have a dart-board at home with a picture of Rachel Alexandra?

NT

[CSC]

Originally Posted by NTamm1215

Do you have a dart-board at home with a picture of Rachel Alexandra?

NT

Obcourse I don't, but I also don't feel questioning a horse even if she is loved by many if not all, a personal attack. It is a single opinion. However I have my reasons, let's see how she progresses from 3 - 4, she ran some awfully fast races from a numbers perspective that may be hard to repeat and regarding the Woodward in my opinion she looked very ordinary. Asmussen is an unknown with returning horses if one wants to use Curlin as an example, I don't rely on beyers as gospel so maybe I look at these 2 differently, one can hope both horses will meet in a race down the line. At this point barring RA improving as a 4 yr old I would say Zenyatta is a better horse, if they had both run in the classic whether it was held at CD or SA, I have no problem saying Zenyatta would have beaten her at 1 1/4.

[slotdirt]

I honestly just wish we had seen Zenyatta on dirt more often. Winning 13 of 14 races on a third surface just doesn't do much for me. Her Apple Blossom, however, was outstanding. Too bad Moss/Shireffs were chicken for the rest of her career.

[CSC]

Originally Posted by slotdirt

I honestly just wish we had seen Zenyatta on dirt more often. Winning 13 of 14 races on a third surface just doesn't do much for me. Her Apple Blossom, however, was outstanding. Too bad Moss/Shireffs were chicken for the rest of her career.

I said it earlier, I think she can be even more dominant on dirt. I agree with the assertion that Sheriff's keeping her on poly has actually kept fans from seeing how much better she could be. Look at her pedigree, and synth beyers are notoriously unreliable and unflattering, if she gets a chance next year who knows where the sky is with her.

[kgar311]

Originally Posted by CSC

Obcourse I don't, but I also don't feel questioning a horse even if she is loved by many if not all, a personal attack. It is a single opinion. However I have my reasons, let's see how she progresses from 3 - 4, she ran some awfully fast races from a numbers perspective that may be hard to repeat and regarding the Woodward in my opinion she looked very ordinary. Asmussen is an unknown with returning horses if one wants to use Curlin as an example, I don't rely on beyers as gospel so maybe I look at these 2 differently, one can hope both horses will meet in a race down the line. At this point barring RA improving as a 4 yr old I would say Zenyatta is a better horse, if they had both run in the classic whether it was held at CD or SA, I have no problem saying Zenyatta would have beaten her at 1 1/4.

Seriously do you have a mental deficiency? She was challenged by every single horse in the race and put them all way. Not only did she do this while sprinting the whole way she had to deal with a fresh Macho Again who did nothing but loaf he first 7 panels and uncorked a huge run at her. She dispatched every horse in the race and still didn't let MA go by here after the wire. Your bias for west coast racing and running on rubber and wax is getting in the way of allowing you to think clearly.

[CSC]

Originally Posted by kgar311

Seriously do you have a mental deficiency? She was challenged by every single horse in the race and put them all way. Not only did she do this while sprinting the whole way she had to deal with a fresh Macho Again who did nothing but loaf he first 7 panels and uncorked a huge run at her. She dispatched every horse in the race and still didn't let MA go by here after the wire. You bias for west coast racing and running on rubber and wax is getting in the way of allowing you to think clearly.

I've read your posts and there is only one person here who has a mental deficiency.

[parsixfarms]

Originally Posted by kgar311

Seriously do you have a mental deficiency? She was challenged by every single horse in the race and put them all way. Not only did she do this while sprinting the whole way she had to deal with a fresh Macho Again who did nothing but loaf he first 7 panels and uncorked a huge run at her. She dispatched every horse in the race and still didn't let MA go by here after the wire. Your bias for west coast racing and running on rubber and wax is getting in the way of allowing you to think clearly.

Can we please stop this she was "sprinting the whole way" nonsense when referring to Rachel's Woodward? Yes, the fractions that she set were fast for a 3YO filly, but she was running in a Grade I race for older horses going 9F at Saratoga. In that historical context, her opening quarter was fast, but her first half and 6F splits were about "average" for such races at Saratoga this decade (and there were 9F races run by NY-breds such as Future Prospect and Fiddlers Afleet this year at Saratoga that were faster to the half).

2002 Whitney (Left Bank): 23.0, 45.4, 1:09.1

2003 Whitney (Medaglia D'oro): 23.2, 46.4, 1:10.2

2004 Whitney (Roses In May): 22.3, 45.1, 1:08.4

2005 Whitney (Commentator): 23.2, 46.2, 1:09.3 (Ironically, many of the same people who have tried to knock Commentator on this board by arguing that he got away with soft fractions in his match-up with Saint Liam are stating that Rachel Alexandra survived a suicidal pace.)

2006 Whitney (Invasor): 23.0, 47.0, 1:11.1

2006 Woodward (Premium Tap): 23.3, 47.1, 1:11.4

2007 Whitney (Lawyer Ron): 23.4, 47.1, 1:10.1

2007 Woodward (Lawyer Ron): 23.1, 46.2, 1:10.2

2008 Whitney (Commentator): 24.0, 47.3, 1:11.4

2008 Woodward (Curlin): 22.4, 46.1, 1:09.3

2009 Whitney (Bullsbay): 23.2, 46.1, 1:10.0

2009 Woodward (Rachel Alexandra): 22.4, 46.2, 1:10.2

[slotdirt]

I'd take Rachel's Haskell over Zenyatta's Classic six days a week and twice on Sunday.