Cast your Dee Tee baseball HoF vote

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Crown@club

Bert Blyleven - He was good. 300 Win benchmark should be less considered.
Andre Dawson - Tops in his playing time
†Rickey Henderson - Automatic
Tommy John - Should get in definitely after writer elgibility
Don Mattingly - some compare him to Kirby Puckett - How do you compare a 1B to an CF? Could take the final year to do it
Mark McGwire - Oh heck why not
Jim Rice - Final year with the writers this year?
Lee Smith - Its time. But if he's in then do you consider closers who past him?

The problem I have with guys like Tommy john is that it is hard to make a case that they wouldnt be the worst pitcher in the hall of fame. Mattingly actually has worse career stats than mark grace. I really have no problem with Lee Smith but there are an awful lot of guys that have similar credentials too.