Colonel John

[jcs11204]

Originally Posted by NTamm1215

It's arbitrary, baseless remarks like this that earn you a great deal of flak on this site...take it from someone who has not chastised you at all.

NT

its not baseless he is a young sire, and has accomplished a lot already, champion, major 3 yr old stakes winners, 2 yr old stakes winners...

[NTamm1215]

Originally Posted by jcs11204

its not baseless he is a young sire, and has accomplished a lot already, champion, major 3 yr old stakes winners, 2 yr old stakes winners...

Right but the original issue was not whether Tiznow is a good sire, that was never denied. The issue was that someone came on here and used one horse as an example as far as how Tiznow is a good turf sire. One horse does not a sire make.

NT

[jcs11204]

Originally Posted by NTamm1215

Right but the original issue was not whether Tiznow is a good sire, that was never denied. The issue was that someone came on here and used one horse as an example as far as how Tiznow is a good turf sire. One horse does not a sire make.

NT

why does he need a good turf horse to be a great sire, maybe i dont get it...
same with giants causeway and dirt, he produces on synthetics and turf, and has had decent dirt runners, so what is he ?