Beware

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by cmorioles

Here are some of the latest G1 route winners on synthetic. How have they done on dirt?

Panty Raid (is this the "good" Lady Joanne performance???)
Dominican
Christmas Kid
Nashoba's Key
Lava Man
Heatseeker
Double Trouble
Golden Doc A
Student Council

Wow, I'm pretty amazed at that dreadful list and I compiled it.

Lava Man was another who ran his best races on the dirt.

Panty Raid ran in the GI Alabama...Lady Joanne beat her in that race soundly. Then they met up again in the Spinster, and Panty Raid barely beat Lady Joanne. Lady Joanne could run on both surfaces well, but was better on the dirt. I think a horse's breeding has a lot to do with it.

[cmorioles]

Originally Posted by kentuckyrosesinmay

Lava Man was another who ran his best races on the dirt.

Panty Raid ran in the GI Alabama...Lady Joanne beat her in that race soundly. Then they met up again in the Spinster, and Panty Raid barely beat Lady Joanne. Lady Joanne could run on both surfaces well, but was better on the dirt. I think a horse's breeding has a lot to do with it.

Lava Man was a set up...he could win on anything.

Lady Joanne had already run, and won, on dirt. I didn't need to see her on synthetic to know what she was about. In retrospect, running a "turf like" race in the Spinster sure didn't help her on BC Day when you consider it was her only race in two and a half months before the Distaff.

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by cmorioles

Lava Man was a set up...he could win on anything.

Lady Joanne had already run, and won, on dirt. I didn't need to see her on synthetic to know what she was about. In retrospect, running a "turf like" race in the Spinster sure didn't help her on BC Day when you consider it was her only race in two and a half months before the Distaff.

Isn't the whole point that horses who can run really well on synthetic like SS, LJ, and LM can be better on the dirt?

Lava Man could win on anything, but was best on the dirt.

Lady Joanne ran her first race on synthetic, which is when I first mentioned the horse to the board. She was better on the dirt though.

Lady Joanne had issues as noted with the break and addition of the front wraps. After the break, she never came close to moving as pretty as she did as a two-year-old. I think she could have been a better horse than she showed when she came back from that long break. So many are like that though...

I am not just going to not put a future wager on a horse as talented as Colonel John just because he is running his butt off on the synthetic surface when his breeding is all dirt. If they have the right breeding and performances, running only on the synthetic before the KD is not going to keep me from betting on them necessarily.

[blackthroatedwind]

Even your emoticons show a complete lack of originality.

[paisjpq]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

Even your emoticons show a complete lack of originality.

one of the first ways that children learn is by imitation.

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

Even your emoticons show a complete lack of originality.

Must we go back to the who is the better of the two horses conversation the other day?

No, I won't because I promised that I wouldn't.