Did Hard Spun clip heels with Street Sense?

I thought we had settled this issue but it has reared its head over on the about website. A fellow there named depalma is responsible for the quote at the beginning of this thread.

He claims that you can see the clipping on the overhead, which I am very doubtful of. I'll have to look at it again.

It has been pointed out that HS runs like this but subsequently it was pointed out by others on about, that a) he did not run like that in the Lanes End and b) he did not bob his head like that on a regular basis in the derby only when changing leads. (depalma on the latter)

I clearly saw HS on the video bow his head before reaching the far turn. Right after the announcer calls out SEdgefield and Teuf. Whta I am not sure of is whether HS is doing this every so often on the backstretch. THought he was but the buildings get in the way. Depalma is sure he didnt do this and only does this when he changes leads.

So the mystery deepens.

THe comment by Tector I dont see as meant to be antagonistic but rather a question as to whether if this was really a clipping some objection would have been voiced. I.e. since the jock didnt object probably it didnt happen, i.e it is circumstantial evidence that it didnt happen. I think that's a fair pt. .

[tector]

Originally Posted by easy goer

The comment by Tector I dont see as meant to be antagonistic but rather a question as to whether if this was really a clipping some objection would have been voiced. I.e. since the jock didnt object probably it didnt happen, i.e it is circumstantial evidence that it didnt happen. I think that's a fair pt. .

My point was meant to question the logic of the author of the post originally posted elsewhere--if this incident, in fact, happened, logic would seem to dictate that SOMEBODY connected to HS would be complaining about it. I take their silence to be a tacit omission that it did not occur.

Peace be with you. Or, as Harvey used to say, may the horse be with you.

[Kasept]

Pino didn't say a word about any contact Saturday night when discussing the trip. You'd think it would have come up had there indeed been even the slightest brush or clip...

[The Bid]

Maybe horse got a little scared when SS came into his path, obviously he was tired, maybe he was a little sore. Who knows why he made that heavy switch, I dont think it was made by contact.

[fpsoxfan]

I'm a science teacher and from what I can see we have several forces at work here. There is Kinetic Energy which is the energy in a moving body, such as the wind, a speeding train, or a tractor trailer. When you are moving and one of these objects passes you, you can feel the wind or forces of this moving object. This can sometimes cause someone to take a funny step or go off course a hair. As Street Sense (speeding train), blew past Hard Spun (person or animal standing/walking/running near the train tracks) causing him to slightly alter his style. We could also get into inertia, speed and velocity, but it is what it is.

[Linny]

Watch the overhead again. It appears the SS's TAIL caught HS's nose when he crossed over. He flips his nose like they do when hit with a whip.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by cmfhb411

Hmmmm. This all sounds a lot like: "It appears Jose's got a buzzer/battery in his hand"................

.........which, of course explains Funny Cide's huge win 2 weeks later.

Again, when I started this thread, I clearly stated that it had no (zero, nada) effect on the race, Pino didn't claim foul or even mention it...it's just something of interest.

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

Again, when I started this thread, I clearly stated that it had no (zero, nada) effect on the race, Pino didn't claim foul or even mention it...it's just something of interest.

Since it is clear from watching the overhead that they did not touch, no claim of foul, no effect on the race, etc, what is so interesting about it?
Thats what I don't get.