American Idol Round of 6: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[Buffymommy]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

They are both great but I'm a big fan of Carrie!

OHHH... I will get to fight with you too!

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by Buffymommy

OHHH... I will get to fight with you too!

Well there's not much to fight about - Carrie is a better pure singer and Kelly is the better overall package. That's my opinion on the ever fluctuating topic of who is better.

[Buffymommy]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

Well there's not much to fight about - Carrie is a better pure singer and Kelly is the better overall package. That's my opinion on the ever fluctuating topic of who is better.

I was just teasing. We all are entitled to our opinions.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

Well there's not much to fight about - Carrie is a better pure singer and Kelly is the better overall package. That's my opinion on the ever fluctuating topic of who is better.

Brian, Buffy...who leaves tonight? This seems like a tough choice...I wouldn't be surprised to see any of the four go...Lakisha has been disappointing for several weeks, Blake was suprisingly in the bottom 3 last week and again...that song choice could give him a problem, Phil and Chris seem to be actually gaining some support...a real crap shoot imo!

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

Brian, Buffy...who leaves tonight? This seems like a tough choice...I wouldn't be surprised to see any of the four go...Lakisha has been disappointing for several weeks, Blake was suprisingly in the bottom 3 last week and again...that song choice could give him a problem, Phil and Chris seem to be actually gaining some support...a real crap shoot imo!

I think that the most likely result tonight is Lakisha's ouster.

Though my phone-in votes system created a four way tie for Mediocraty Champion last night, so any of those four could go -- though Chris or Lakisha seem the most at risk, with only Jordin and Melinda looking truly safe.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

I think that the most likely result tonight is Lakisha's ouster.

Though my phone-in votes system created a four way tie for Mediocraty Champion last night, so any of those four could go -- though Chris or Lakisha seem the most at risk, with only Jordin and Melinda looking truly safe.

I kinda agree...LaKisha is certainly at risk as she suffers from comparison to Melinda and Jordin, any of the guys could go but Chris since he sang first may be forgotten, Phil seemed doomed just a couple weeks ago but seems to be gaining support...country songs have saved him for now.

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

I kinda agree...LaKisha is certainly at risk as she suffers from comparison to Melinda and Jordin, any of the guys could go but Chris since he sang first may be forgotten, Phil seemed doomed just a couple weeks ago but seems to be gaining support...country songs have saved him for now.

But he's still creepy and not very good when placed side-by-side with a Jordin or a Melinda. Jordan told me last night, "He could win." He said it mostly to get me angry and get a response out of me -- but let's just put to rest any notion that he's somehow injected himself into this competition (not saying you think that...).

[Buffymommy]

Bottom three SHOULD be: Phil; Chris; Lakisha. With Phil or Chris going home. IMO.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

But he's still creepy and not very good when placed side-by-side with a Jordin or a Melinda. Jordan told me last night, "He could win." He said it mostly to get me angry and get a response out of me -- but let's just put to rest any notion that he's somehow injected himself into this competition (not saying you think that...).

Oh I agree, he's no danger to the top 2...I suspect the final three will contain one of the three guys but I'm not sure which one!