American Idol Round of 8: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

4) Haley...I agree that her vocal wasn't her best, she seemed on-key to me but had difficulty projecting the words. Still, she has something the others, except for Jordin, didn't show...personality and charisma. Love her expressions, the little smiles and winks, playful and naughty...fun to watch. And Simon was right...wear as little as possible!

Ahhh the Haley apologist strikes again!

Easily the worst tonight, no discussing it. Let alone FOURTH!???!?!

PS, idol is on fox, not whatever channel you were watching with some scantily clad girl named Haley that gave a decent showing of herself