Ranking

[POINTGIVEN1985]

Originally Posted by NTamm1215

A typically strong response from you.

To answer the question posed, I will rank them because I do think more than one have a legitimate shot to win the Derby.

1.) Any Given Saturday- Ran the worst race of his life while wide in a race that he was originally not even supposed to be running in. He will improve off it and show that he is absolutely not 5 lengths worse than 'Nobiz.
2.) Scat Daddy- He's done the most on the track of any of Pletcher's bunch and as the preps keep coming in with ho-hum results his stock skyrockets.
3.) Circular Quay- Tons of raw talent, but the 8 week layoff has to make even the sternest of folks uneasy.
4.) Cowtown Cat- He definitely was the beneficiary of a free and clear trip in Illinois, but he validated what I considered to be a questionable win in the Gotham.
5-8.) Deadly Dealer, Sam P., King of the Roxy, Soaring By, etc.- I don't think any of these have a great shot, but we'll learn more about DD and Soaring By this week and next week.

I think it's a little premature to say that Todd P won't even get in the superfecta.

NT

well i do feel very strong about this i dont think he has any shot to win the derby i think his whole stable of 3 year olds is overrated and none of them did anything this past saturday to make me feel any different about them.


Any given saturday runs horrible

Sam p and King of the roxy cant beat a maiden winner in Tiago

The only one who won was Cowtown cat and i will just agree with what you said above.....

I will rank them though

Circular Quay
Rags to riches

those are the top 2 in my opinion