American Idol Round of 11: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by Buffymommy

I missed Haley so I can't judge her.

Chris R-was decent in my opinion. I like a good ole boy though.

Stef-BORING. She sounded nice, but I didn't want to watch or listen. I actually got up and went into the other room to fold laundry.

Blake-I actully really liked him tonight. Not the best vocal, but Good and his presentation was great. I liked what he did with the song.

Lakisha-Not her best, but still very good.

Phil-I like this guy, but it was not the best. (Bottom three bound)

Jordin-LOVE HER! Enough said. WOW!

Sanjaya-PLEASE GO HOME THIS WEEK (Bottom three bound though)

Gina-I liked the performance but not the best vocal.

Chris S-I like her. Not his best, but still good.

Melinda-She is good.

Bottom three in my opinion: Phil; Sanjaya; and Haley.

Buffy, how can you admit not hearing Haley and still rank her in bottom three?