American Idol Week 3: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by ArlJim78

My rankings;

1) Melinda - Classy, beat her to take the title
2) Lakeisha - talented and working well, not ideal post position
3) Jordin - steps up against elders, has shot
4) Stephanie - consistent grinder type, must show more
5) Sabrina - off form last few tries, can rebound
6) Antonella - geogeous looking filly, steps up in class
7) Haley - in deep, must do more
8) Gina - doesn't have the class for this

Juxtapose 6 and 8 and I am in total agreement. I find that I am, while I'm trying to be serious, using horseplaying terms in talking about the competition.

Like Melinda, strictly the one to beat....beat her to cash.

I'll throw you a bone even, I'd take 6.) Gina 7.) Antonella 8.) Haley

Any ranking that leaves Antonella out of the bottom two is inherently flawed, especially if it is an overall ranking as yours claims to be AJ.

I could see putting her #6 tonight, but not overall.