Jerry Brown's letter to TDN on HOY discussion

[CSC]

Originally Posted by kgar311

Are you calling her competition in those 3 races grade 1 caliber??? Come on now those races were grade 1 in name only contested against horses that would be 40k claimers in NY.

This argument can be made both ways. Or haven't you seen how Macho Again and Bullsbay have raced after the Woodward. I'm not looking for a long winded reply because this will turn into a merry go round exchange that has been said many times over this week...month, I'm just saying that argument can be made both ways.

[kgar311]

Originally Posted by CSC

This argument can be made both ways. Or haven't you seen how Macho Again and Bullsbay have raced after the Woodward. I'm not looking for a long winded reply because this will turn into a merry go round exchange that has been said many times over this week...month, I'm just saying that argument can be made both ways.

you are right and its a damn shame that sh*t plastic made a champ like Curlin look like a 40 claimer. Its a travesty. Dirt is the bar not plastic

[Smooth Operator]

Originally Posted by kgar311

you are right and its a damn shame that sh*t plastic made a champ like Curlin look like a 40 claimer. Its a travesty. Dirt is the bar not plastic

You must be joking, kgar311 … the surface had nothing to do with Curlin getting exposed, imo.

He was the Winstrol "champ" … the Barry Bonds of horses, if you will.

Never had that same acceleration after the 'roid influence waned in spring of '08.