All conventional wisdom may be lost...

KYrosesinMay
if you remeber our discussion on this matter
I suggested the same thing as this proposal
and you and the rest jumped down my throat
now a "published writer" says the same thing
and everybody buys into it? stealing my thunder
possibly from reading this very board
bunch of robots! programmed by the media

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.

KYrosesinMay
if you remeber our discussion on this matter
I suggested the same thing as this proposal
and you and the rest jumped down my throat
now a "published writer" says the same thing
and everybody buys into it? stealing my thunder
possibly from reading this very board
bunch of robots! programmed by the media

Actually BR, everyone on this board is basically saying that if Bernardini wins HOY, then it will be ridiculous if Barbaro wins the 3 yo title because Bernardini will be deserving of both titles if he wins the BCC. In fact, I believe everyone has said that what the author of the article has proposed is completely ridiculous.

[Cajungator26]

Originally Posted by kentuckyrosesinmay

Actually BR, everyone on this board is basically saying that if Bernardini wins HOY, then it will be ridiculous if Barbaro wins the 3 yo title because Bernardini will be deserving of both titles if he wins the BCC. In fact, I believe everyone has said that what the author of the article has proposed is completely ridiculous.

Yes, but what he was saying was that he proposed the idea first that it MAY happen.

Originally Posted by kentuckyrosesinmay

Actually BR, everyone on this board is basically saying that if Bernardini wins HOY, then it will be ridiculous if Barbaro wins the 3 yo title because Bernardini will be deserving of both titles if he wins the BCC. In fact, I believe everyone has said that what the author of the article has proposed is completely ridiculous.

fact it you posted the article
another fact is I stated it originally
what anyone else thinks is moot!

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.

fact it you posted the article
another fact is I stated it originally
what anyone else thinks is moot!

The reason I posted the article is because I thought that having Barbaro as 3 yo champ and Bernardini as HOY was completely ridiculous. I can't believe that anyone in the industry could actually give Barbaro 3 yo honors if Bernardini wins the BCC and is HOY. It makes no sense. There do need to be some changes made in the game, but this is not one of them.

Originally Posted by kentuckyrosesinmay

The reason I posted the article is because I thought that having Barbaro as 3 yo champ and Bernardini as HOY was completely ridiculous. I can't believe that anyone in the industry could actually give Barbaro 3 yo honors if Bernardini wins the BCC and is HOY. It makes no sense. There do need to be some changes made in the game, but this is not one of them.

yeah, but you also have to consider
that you are as dumb as a box of rocks...

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.

yeah, but you also have to consider
that you are as dumb as a box of rocks...

I guess that you are entitled to an opinion (LOL) although it is a very childish one. Really BR, I don't feel like getting into it with you. I don't have to because that statement came out of nowhere and you just lost what little credibility you had...

Boy, do I have some haters on this board...LOL

Let me ask you a question, if I am as dumb as a box of rocks, then what does that make those who agreed with me on this subject, which was everyone but you on this board? Humor me.

[Cajungator26]

Originally Posted by kentuckyrosesinmay

I guess that you are entitled to an opinion (LOL) although it is a very childish one. Really BR, I don't feel like getting into it with you. I don't have to because that statement came out of nowhere and you just lost what little credibility you had...

Boy, do I have some haters on this board...LOL

Let me ask you a question, if I am as dumb as a box of rocks, then what does that make those who agreed with me on this subject, which was everyone but you on this board? Humor me.

Let's not start with this today. Good heavens, I get a headache just thinking about it. LMFAO For the record, I DO NOT hate you or think you are dumb. I just think that things come across a different way on a message board than they do in person.

Originally Posted by Cajungator26

That's highly disgusting and degrading. To take it that far shows no class at all.

Cajun, hows this?
Betsy, we know how you feel about Bernadini, you've been letting us know for quite some time now.
But for you to tell Haskin what he should think is HYSTERICAL!!!
His theory makes more sense than you telling us that Bernadini has definitely done enough at this point without beating elders to wrest away the championship from Barbaro.
They both won tri crown races with Barabaro taking the elite race, against a field of 20, because bernadini "wasn't up to that yet". Barabaro also won his previous three races, all graded, with the Florida derby being amongst them.
Its about pretty equal at this point. Certainly debatable, but for you to say he doesnt need to beat elders and speak condescendingly towards Haskins theory at the same time is pretty funny.

Lets stay on topic, shall we?

I think Bernardini is a lock for 3 year old champion. Why? Because I am good at Tetris.

[Linny]

Obviously the whole idea is based upon a "what if..." If you don't buy the premise, then you have no comment.

If Bernardini does win the BCC, then he should get 3yo and HOY honors. If he's not entitled to be called the "best 3yo male" then how can he be HOY. Voting in a HOY who didn't even win his division makes the Awards a joke.