Workout injury ends Big Brown Cup hopes, career..

[philcski]

Originally Posted by RollerDoc

Partially yes. Especially when they are of the prestige of FL Derby, KY Derby, Preakness, and Haskell. Now if those four were all titled the Monmouth Stakes, then no. That is not the only reason why he has had the best year of any horse in 2008 although it does speak volumes. Add to that in three of them, he blew away the field, and in two of them, he won from the outside post (KY Derby was even more amazing post 20).

Give it up. It's not worth defending him, for one you won't win the argument and two there is no definitive answer.

Just so you know, for my money, Big Brown is HOY unless Curlin wins the BC or if Curlin doesn't, then Zenyatta has a chance to steal it with a dominating Distaff or even moreso with a Classic win.

[RollerDoc]

Originally Posted by philcski

Give it up. It's not worth defending him, for one you won't win the argument and two there is no definitive answer.

Just so you know, for my money, Big Brown is HOY unless Curlin wins the BC or if Curlin doesn't, then Zenyatta has a chance to steal it with a dominating Distaff or even moreso with a Classic win.

I figured Big Brown could only have won HOY had he won the BCC. Interesting to know he is still in the running. Even if he cannot run.