Jeremy Rose

[Indian Charlie]

Dude, I just watched the Chief Export 'incident'.

Clearly that was accidental, as if you look real closely, you can see he was swatting at a gnat that was bothering the horse. The shoulder, unfortunately, just got in the way.

In retrospect, it was actually the horse that was to blame.

[ArlJim78]

I am 100% sure that he cracked that horse in the face 2-3 times.
you can debate what his intention was or what the punishment should be all you want, but what happened cannot be debated. In my opinion he doesn't belong around thoroughbreds.