Big Brown - Overrated?

[Bobby Fischer]

can i box it ?

Brown,Curlin,Barbaro,Bernardini


This is hard if you think about running styles. Barbaro was so game on the front end - it could take something out of Brown or vice versa.

[ArlJim78]

you can't have Bernardini without Invasor!

Invasor/Bernardini/Curlin/Brown/Barbaro

[Antitrust32]

Discreet Cat would have whooped all of there butts

[smuthg]

Originally Posted by ArlJim78

you can't have Bernardini without Invasor!

Invasor/Bernardini/Curlin/Brown/Barbaro

I don't think its fair to put Barbaro on this list because of the unknowns, but I think Curlin would have eaten Berni alive and Curlin v. Invasor would be a serious horse race. Big Brown is more Berni than the others right now.

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by smuthg

I don't think its fair to put Barbaro on this list because of the unknowns, but I think Curlin would have eaten Berni alive and Curlin v. Invasor would be a serious horse race. Big Brown is more Berni than the others right now.

none of this is fair or important, and its all subjective for the most part. its just the kind of stuff we pass the time with on forums like this.

[smuthg]

Originally Posted by ArlJim78

none of this is fair or important, and its all subjective for the most part. its just the kind of stuff we pass the time with on forums like this.

agreed...