Reds trade Josh Hamilton to the Rangers

[Cannon Shell]

Hamilton is a superior talent but has a lot of question marks surrounding him and always will. The pitchers the Reds got have live arms which is something that they really need.

[whodey17]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Hamilton is a superior talent but has a lot of question marks surrounding him and always will. The pitchers the Reds got have live arms which is something that they really need.

He had the potential of being an all time great. I really enjoy watching him play. But like u said, the reds need pitching.

[Scav]

Originally Posted by whodey17

He had the potential of being an all time great. I really enjoy watching him play. But like u said, the reds need pitching.

all time great?

Come on now, he is a good player, but never would get into the hall of fame

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Scav

all time great?

Come on now, he is a good player, but never would get into the hall of fame

He is scary good but will probably never string together enough healthy years for HOF status. Though he is ahead of Garvey at the moment.

[GPK]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

He is scary good but will probably never string together enough healthy years for HOF status. Though he is ahead of Garvey at the moment.

5...4....3....2....1...

[whodey17]

Originally Posted by Scav

all time great?

Come on now, he is a good player, but never would get into the hall of fame

I said he HAD the potential of an all time great. He is only 26 so he might be able to string together a couple of good years. He lost almost 7 years of his baseball career to drugs. If he remained cleaned, he could have broken into the majors at the age of 20.