Manny

[horseofcourse]

Originally Posted by Mortimer

I stand fast by my decision to get him outa town and put Vizquel,Jr. at short.



I would take Fermin,Franco and Duffy over Here's Jhonny any day.

You are beyond crazy!! Jhonny's made every single play you can make this series with the glove. OF course, I'm ignoring the fact he completely turned the series around from disaster with his 3 run homer in game 2 and his rally starting walk and 1st to 3rd in the 6th inning allowed them to get the game to extra innings. I'm guessing you'd probably take Rick Manning over Grady Sizemore as well and Andy Allansen over Victor Martinez. And Rick Waits over CC Sabathia.

[Mortimer]

Originally Posted by horseofcourse

You are beyond crazy!! Jhonny's made every single play you can make this series with the glove. OF course, I'm ignoring the fact he completely turned the series around from disaster with his 3 run homer in game 2 and his rally starting walk and 1st to 3rd in the 6th inning allowed them to get the game to extra innings. I'm guessing you'd probably take Rick Manning over Grady Sizemore as well and Andy Allansen over Victor Martinez. And Rick Waits over CC Sabathia.

What I am saying is I will always take a good fielding shortstop over a poor one.


I would still like you to cite the hit Peralta has taken away from someone.



Anyone.

[Mortimer]

AAAAND...I would stick FG in center and move Sizeless to left...for next season.

[Mortimer]

Originally Posted by horseofcourse

You are beyond crazy!! Jhonny's made every single play you can make this series with the glove. OF course, I'm ignoring the fact he completely turned the series around from disaster with his 3 run homer in game 2 and his rally starting walk and 1st to 3rd in the 6th inning allowed them to get the game to extra innings. I'm guessing you'd probably take Rick Manning over Grady Sizemore as well and Andy Allansen over Victor Martinez. And Rick Waits over CC Sabathia.

He makes the average play....but not always..although he has this post season...sorta/kinda.


I LOVED that dashing charge he made last night and then threw a frog to first base.


A GOOD fielding shorstop...and that's an out.



And I hasten to remind you of the night he made THREE higlight plays in one game as displayed by sports center this season..




..and it wasn't because they were GOOD ..either.

[horseofcourse]

Originally Posted by Mortimer

He makes the average play....but not always..although he has this post season...sorta/kinda.


I LOVED that dashing charge he made last night and then threw a frog to first base.


A GOOD fielding shorstop...and that's an out.



And I hasten to remind you of the night he made THREE higlight plays in one game as displayed by sports center this season..




..and it wasn't because they were GOOD ..either.

YEs, we must get rid of that Peralta character ASAP...what good is he??