American Idol - 5/22

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by Seattleallstar

Jordin DOES NOT blow out my Katherine out of the water you must be nuts

Seattle, think with the head that is attached to your neck, not the other one...Jordin is in a different class vocally than Katherine...Jordin could end up the best of the Idols, certainly she in the top three...that is unless America goes nuts and selects Blake. At 17 she's just learning but that voice will always be there...just like with Elvis, he got fat and drugged out but the voice was there until the end (no, I'm not saying Jordin is on a level with the King, just using him as an example of someone who above everything, had a fantastic voice)...LaKisha and Stephanie were quite good vocally as was Gina this year and Haley has a few positives as well. The guys were a weak group but Blake still is a better singer than Taylor Hicks...in fact, probably Chris and Phil are as good as Hicks. Last year was rock bottom at the finals, even worse than America's Teddy Bear.

[Byebyemermaid]

I think Jordin will win and she deserves it.I love the fact that she is the daughter of an ex NY Giant cornerback.But strictly as a marketing issue i think Blake will be better.

[Cajungator26]

Originally Posted by Byebyemermaid

I think Jordin will win and she deserves it.I love the fact that she is the daughter of an ex NY Giant cornerback.But strictly as a marketing issue i think Blake will be better.

I won't be buying his album. Not impressed at all, sorry.

[Byebyemermaid]

Originally Posted by Cajungator26

I won't be buying his album. Not impressed at all, sorry.

Jaimie you're not 16 anymore either.

[Cajungator26]

Originally Posted by Byebyemermaid

Jaimie you're not 16 anymore either.

Drat! Oh to be young again... lol.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by Cajungator26

Drat! Oh to be young again... lol.

Yeah but if you were a teenybopper, you'd have to buy Sanjaya's album too!

[Buffymommy]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

Yeah but if you were a teenybopper, you'd have to buy Sanjaya's album too!

OH GROSS! Please! I would rather listen to Paris Hilton sing.

[Byebyemermaid]

Originally Posted by Cajungator26

Drat! Oh to be young again... lol.

I'm glad that you have a good sense of humor.I'm 49 and despite Jordin being only 17 she appeals to me more than Blake because of her amazing voice{better than Melinda}.But they're not looking to target people my age but rather the teenage set.Blake has a gimmick and gimmicks sell to that age group.

[Seattleallstar]

jordin doesnt look like an american idol she has avg face, and using the word chunky is putting it mildly

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by Byebyemermaid

I'm glad that you have a good sense of humor.I'm 49 and despite Jordin being only 17 she appeals to me more than Blake because of her amazing voice{better than Melinda}.But they're not looking to target people my age but rather the teenage set.Blake has a gimmick and gimmicks sell to that age group.

Well that's true but Carrie Underwood won and country supposedly has a limited fan base compared to pop (not sure if that's true). Carrie was clearly the best as is Jordin (now that Melinda is gone). Sanjaya had that teenybopper support along with Stern and Votefortheworst yet it wasn't enough to carry him...I think Jordin wins easily!