American Idol - 5/22

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by Seattleallstar

worst season of Idol just freakin putrid. I havent seen it in a while, just tuned in last night. This is insane bad

It wasn't the worst season...look at last year's "winner" ! I will however consider it the worst result if Blake wins. Jordin should win this by 20 million votes! It would have been a completely different show last night I suspect if it would have been Jordin and Melinda. I didn't watch it but I can imagine Blake was less than awe-inspiring.

[Seattleallstar]

Taylor Hicks wasnt Blake bad, plus there was Katherine McPhee for 2nd and she outshines anyone that was in the finals this year.

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by Seattleallstar

Taylor Hicks wasnt Blake bad, plus there was Katherine McPhee for 2nd and she outshines anyone that was in the finals this year.

I think you've basically juxtaposed the two seasons, as Blake is not as bad as Taylor Hicks, and Jordin blows Katherine Mcphee out of the water.

[Seattleallstar]

Jordin DOES NOT blow out my Katherine out of the water you must be nuts

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by Seattleallstar

Jordin DOES NOT blow out my Katherine out of the water you must be nuts

In terms of tramping oneself out for record sales, maybe.

You got me there.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by Seattleallstar

Jordin DOES NOT blow out my Katherine out of the water you must be nuts

Seattle, think with the head that is attached to your neck, not the other one...Jordin is in a different class vocally than Katherine...Jordin could end up the best of the Idols, certainly she in the top three...that is unless America goes nuts and selects Blake. At 17 she's just learning but that voice will always be there...just like with Elvis, he got fat and drugged out but the voice was there until the end (no, I'm not saying Jordin is on a level with the King, just using him as an example of someone who above everything, had a fantastic voice)...LaKisha and Stephanie were quite good vocally as was Gina this year and Haley has a few positives as well. The guys were a weak group but Blake still is a better singer than Taylor Hicks...in fact, probably Chris and Phil are as good as Hicks. Last year was rock bottom at the finals, even worse than America's Teddy Bear.

[Byebyemermaid]

I think Jordin will win and she deserves it.I love the fact that she is the daughter of an ex NY Giant cornerback.But strictly as a marketing issue i think Blake will be better.

[Cajungator26]

Originally Posted by Byebyemermaid

I think Jordin will win and she deserves it.I love the fact that she is the daughter of an ex NY Giant cornerback.But strictly as a marketing issue i think Blake will be better.

I won't be buying his album. Not impressed at all, sorry.