American Idol Week 3: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by Pillow Pants

Props to Blake for covering 311
Props to Sligh for being a fat nerd with sideshow bob hair.

The rest...suck

that sums up my review rather concisely.

As Randy would say "Blake keeps it real, dog"

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by ArlJim78

that sums up my review rather concisely.

As Randy would say "Blake keeps it real, dog"

It's interesting, I found nothing to like in Blake's performance, maybe it's just the song choice or maybe it's just me but I thought he was very average.

Originally Posted by somerfrost

It's interesting, I found nothing to like in Blake's performance, maybe it's just the song choice or maybe it's just me but I thought he was very average.

It wasn't a great performance...not even close. BUT he gets props for singing a song he actually listens to. I find it hard to believe a few of those guys listen to some of the songs they sing. For example, Sanjaya should be singing Wham!, Army of Lovers, Elton John, George Michael, Culture Club, or Queen.

Blake is keeping it real...Isn't that right dawg pound? Yeeeeuh!! Yeeeeuh!

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by Pillow Pants

For example, Sanjaya should be singing Wham!, Army of Lovers, Elton John, George Michael, Culture Club, or Queen.

Or Britney Spears.

A hot mess is a hot mess any way you cut it.

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

Or Britney Spears.

A hot mess is a hot mess any way you cut it.

OH man, my nomination for good true line of the night!

[Samarta]

They were all brutal last night....all of them....I think they should make an executive decision and do away with that 6 and 6 crap...in fact, I found it interesting that the judges last night were basically saying that....they felt that only 4 should go on....I just hope that Sanjaya kid goes home.....hell I bet there are some better voices than that on this site....

[brianwspencer]

Perhaps tonight will give us more to talk about.

I didn't realize it would be so little fun when we all agreed that they were bad

At least tonight Somer and AJ can apologize for Antonella and make more excuses for her again after she butchers her third straight song.

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

It's interesting, I found nothing to like in Blake's performance, maybe it's just the song choice or maybe it's just me but I thought he was very average.

the performance and vocals, perhaps they were only somewhat ordinary tonight. I just gave extra points for not going with the same tired song/artist choices. He keeps it a little fresher I think with choices like 311 and Jamiroquai