Seacrest should be dismissed

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by ArlJim78

I fail to see why you're more free to speak the truth than anyone else. I certainly wasn't giving her a free pass. My comment was not in regard to her looks. In my opinion she is not absolutely terrible.

She is for sure not in the top flight of this crop, I suspect that very few are, and she won't be in the finals. But in my view she does compare with those in the second tier.

I'm insulted by that accusation...I really am! I thought she sang better than 2-3 other girls...easily! I don't care if she Jenna Jameson or Mother Teresa, my evaluation is my opinion of her singing and I like her voice and presentation...I'd rank her 7th of the 10 girls right now! IMO, she should get through at least one more round!

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

I'm insulted by that accusation...I really am! I thought she sang better than 2-3 other girls...easily! I don't care if she Jenna Jameson or Mother Teresa, my evaluation is my opinion of her singing and I like her voice and presentation...I'd rank her 7th of the 10 girls right now! IMO, she should get through at least one more round!

Just so I'm clear, are you insulted by something I said, or are you quoting me because you agree with me? I actually agree with what you have just said about her.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by ArlJim78

Just so I'm clear, are you insulted by something I said, or are you quoting me because you agree with me? I actually agree with what you have just said about her.

Yeah, I was referring to Brian's comments...and I'm not really insulted just joking with him! But I am serious about my evaluation that she's 7th right now...she could with a good performance next week (if she's still there) become one of the top 12.

[onebadbeast]

Wow, Cant Picture Byk Watching Idol? Anyway, The Black Girls Are Way Above The Rest And Barba Is A Terrible Singer Who Should Be A Model. That One Scat Girl Has A Clown Face, And The Chub From Chicago Wont Make It Either. Not Much Of A Group This Year So Far!

[ddthetide]

last night was the first we watched since the first 2 weeks. Lakisha and Melinda are so FAR ahead of the reat it's not close. Jordin and Sabrina are a tie for 3rd and the rest are behind them. Leslie, that sings the jazz or scat is good at that, she's different from the rest. JMO.