11 race BC not stupid enough..

[horseofcourse]

What about the 16 furlong dirt race for geldings aged 8 and above??

[SniperSB23]

Originally Posted by horseofcourse

What about the 16 furlong dirt race for geldings aged 8 and above??

I'd honestly prefer they add something like that. If they are going to cheapen the BC races at least do them in ways that won't deplete the existing 11 races. I think a turf sprint is fine but can't see any other races they can add without depleting others. Make those 12 BC races, add four G3s for $250,000 and you'll have a very nice two day card. 16 BC races would be awful.

[horseofcourse]

Originally Posted by SniperSB23

I'd honestly prefer they add something like that. If they are going to cheapen the BC races at least do them in ways that won't deplete the existing 11 races. I think a turf sprint is fine but can't see any other races they can add without depleting others. Make those 12 BC races, add four G3s for $250,000 and you'll have a very nice two day card. 16 BC races would be awful.

I think even the races they added this year are too many. I like the full strong fields on the 8 race cards and even those aren't always full as someone earlier said...the turf this year.

[SniperSB23]

Originally Posted by horseofcourse

I think even the races they added this year are too many. I like the full strong fields on the 8 race cards and even those aren't always full as someone earlier said...the turf this year.

I think that given time the three additional races would have been a big positive. Two year old turf racing would have drastically improved and we would have seen a lot of stakes winning 3yos that couldn't get ten furlongs actually stick around for the Dirt Mile at the end of the year instead of being retired mid-season. Plus we need a BC race for Sir Greeley and Wanderin Boy. Unforunately if the five additional races are added it will just be a giant cluster**** and those races won't have a chance to be established as legit BC races. They'll forever be associated with the downfall of the Breeders Cup.

[txshorns02]

i feel like the turf sprint is a good idea and i sort of like the 1 1/4 turf race is good because of some horses that couldnt make 1 1/2 mile and the mile is to short for them...idk how it will turn out...it might just make everything go down hill

[SniperSB23]

Originally Posted by txshorns02

i feel like the turf sprint is a good idea and i sort of like the 1 1/4 turf race is good because of some horses that couldnt make 1 1/2 mile and the mile is to short for them...idk how it will turn out...it might just make everything go down hill

Personally I don't think there is as big a difference between 8 and 12 furlongs on the turf as there is between 6 and 10 furlongs on the dirt. While I think a race in the middle will work on the dirt without causing major dilution to the other two races I don't agree that it would be the case on the turf.

Given the miserable ratings on ESPN for the Breeders' Cup, I don't see how expanding the program does anything for the sport. Creating races for all of the niches in racing only dilutes public interest and knowledge in racing. It's like when General Motors starting making full lines of cars within each division instead of just a few cars so that there was a logical progression from Chevy to Pontiac to Olds to Buick to Cadillac. We know how things worked out for GM. Too many divisions is just too complicated for attracting general interest and racing needs some general interest and needs it soon.

If anything, there should only be 4 Breeders' Cup Races: The Sprint, The Turf, the Classic and the Steeplechase and all of the races should not be age or gender restricted. Maybe that way, at least some Eclipse Awards wouldn't be based on a one to four race campaign and juveniles would be given a more appropriate foundation entering their 3 year old seasons.

[SniperSB23]

If 16 races are going to happen and there is nothing we can do then I think this is the best way to spread the 16 races:

Juv
Juv Fillies
Juv Turf
Juv Fillies Turf
Turf Sprint
Turf Mile
Turf
FM Turf Sprint
FM Turf Mile
FM Turf (12 furlongs)
Sprint
Dirt Mile
Classic
FM Sprint
FM Dirt Mile
FM Distaff (10 furlongs)

I don't especially like it but I think it is the best you can do if forced to pick 16 BC races while minimizing races stepping on each others toes. Do we really need a champion female turf sprinter? No. But I'd rather have that race on a 16 race BC program than a race that will steal more horses from another race on the card.