Secret Oath

Originally Posted by freddymo

Didn't Jerry Brown buy Twitter? Vic, she was one of the 4 most likely winners, a ten-year-old looking at the form for 2 months would have realized she was as least as likely as any filly to win. Ultimately you are splitting hairs when handicapping a race like that. Nobody in their right mind thought she was an X. I liked Kathleen the best I thought she was most likely. You are making a filly that has never run an above par G1 figure a killer she isn't. Let it go leave the great talk for Rachel who would have beat her by a pole. I actually think given the dynamics of the race Echo Zulu ran as well as Secret Oath. We don't know if EZ needs one turn to blossom or just may need more seasoning as she obviously started late. That said would you be surprised if any of the other 3 fillies won the division? Sure S.O. is the leader right now but we are just getting started.

Freddy, the very concept of becoming generational means it takes a while to achieve.

All I've ever said is I "think" she has a chance to develop into that.

Jerry compared her to EIGHT BELLES "before" yesterdays race. In fact he did it even before the Arkansas Derby.

I said what I said after an allowance race at Oaklawn.

Last time I made that kind of prediction it was about a horse named ZENYATTA in her 2nd career start.

SECRET OATH'S win yesterday was certainly impressive. Is she "generational" yet. No of course not.

Can she become that? I think so, but I respect what others on here have to say and would like to hear your opinions as well.

[freddymo]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

Freddy, the very concept of becoming generational means it takes a while to achieve.

All I've ever said is I "think" she has a chance to develop into that.

Jerry compared her to EIGHT BELLES "before" yesterdays race. In fact he did it even before the Arkansas Derby.

I said what I said after an allowance race at Oaklawn.

Last time I made that kind of prediction it was about a horse named ZENYATTA in her 2nd career start.

SECRET OATH'S win yesterday was certainly impressive. Is she "generational" yet. No of course not.

Can she become that? I think so, but I respect what others on here have to say and would like to hear your opinions as well.

I think she is fine and used her defensively, I thoroughly enjoyed watching her win, I think any of the top 4 fillies could go on to be extremely good. I wouldn't wager she will ever run a 105+ figure. I actually hope I am wrong but I really do not think she is anything but a good G1 type. I can think of a dozen fillies at this stage in their career that I knew were faster and more talented than she is.

[RolloTomasi]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

Freddy, the very concept of becoming generational means it takes a while to achieve.

All I've ever said is I "think" she has a chance to develop into that.

Not quite...

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

IMO she's a generational talent.

Jerry compared her to EIGHT BELLES "before" yesterdays race. In fact he did it even before the Arkansas Derby.

Me too; does that mean my anonymous opinion count? Or do I need to get a hot walking job first?

Originally Posted by RolloTomasi

Not for nothing, Eight Belles did the same to one degree or another in the Martha Washington, Honey Bee, and Fantasy. Could have been DQ'd in the latter. Similar physique and stride. Same sire line, too (Unbridled's Song).

Last time I made that kind of prediction it was about a horse named ZENYATTA in her 2nd career start.

I guess that makes you smarter than David Flores at least...

Originally Posted by RolloTomasi

Not quite...

David was sick about taking off her. He knew she was good. But had a chance to ride a Derby horse for Craig Dollace named El Gato Malo.

I would have done the same thing.

Never know.




Me too; does that mean my anonymous opinion count? Or do I need to get a hot walking job first?




I guess that makes you smarter than David Flores at least...

David was sick about taking off her. He knew she was good. But had a chance to ride a Derby horse for Craig Dollace named El Gato Malo.

I would have done the same thing.

Never know.

You guys have my word of honor.

I won't let the trolls get to me anymore.

I'll participate in talking about our great sport.

Or I'll abstain.

I'm guilty of the dysfunction too.

Sorry.

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

You guys have my word of honor.

I won't let the trolls get to me anymore.

I'll participate in talking about our great sport.

Or I'll abstain.

I'm guilty of the dysfunction too.

Sorry.

You're like a Used Car Salesman. Nobody here is buying it.

We know a troll when we see one.

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

You're like a Used Car Salesman. Nobody here is buying it.

We know a troll when we see one.

So what do you think about running the filly in the Preakness?

[freddymo]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

So what do you think about running the filly in the Prerakness?

She ran a 94 BSF and now head to a spot she will need to run 5pts faster to be in the mix? You realize they have some nice filly races like the Phipps Alabama Coaching Club etc. ?

[King Glorious]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

So what do you think about running the filly in the Prerakness?

I wouldn’t run her in the Preakness and definitely not in the Belmont. But not because she’s a filly. I wouldn’t run a colt in either of those races either unless I had won or skipped the Derby. As for later in the year, I’d absolutely be open to trying a race like the Haskell or Travers or Penn Derby. I don’t think there’s anything to lose. If she wins or runs well, it doesn’t hurt her reputation and she can always return to her own division. Pretty much like the Arkansas Derby.

[Dahoss]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

You guys have my word of honor.

I won't let the trolls get to me anymore.

I'll participate in talking about our great sport.

Or I'll abstain.

I'm guilty of the dysfunction too.

Sorry.

Apology accepted.

Be better.

Originally Posted by Dahoss

Apology accepted.

Be better.

So what do we think about the filly running in the Preakness?

[Dahoss]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

So what do we think about the filly running in the Preakness?

I’m not playing your games Vic.

[Dahoss]

Originally Posted by v j stauffer

Freddy, the very concept of becoming generational means it takes a while to achieve.

All I've ever said is I "think" she has a chance to develop into that.

Jerry compared her to EIGHT BELLES "before" yesterdays race. In fact he did it even before the Arkansas Derby.

I said what I said after an allowance race at Oaklawn.

Last time I made that kind of prediction it was about a horse named ZENYATTA in her 2nd career start.

SECRET OATH'S win yesterday was certainly impressive. Is she "generational" yet. No of course not.

Can she become that? I think so, but I respect what others on here have to say and would like to hear your opinions as well.

ME ME ME ME ME