Hypothetical Derby 1995-1999

[miraja2]

Originally Posted by eurobounce

For me it is SILVER CHARM SILVER CHARM SILVER CHARM.

Is it me, or does this field from 1995-1999 seem real real weak compared to the field from 2000-2006?

It is not just you Euro. I think with this group it would have to be Silver Charm and Thunder Gulch.
Your list is not bad, but it would probably be better to just do the entire decade. That way you get horses like AP Indy, Tabasco Cat, Prairie Bayou etc. in the mix.