American Idol Round of 9: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[Cajungator26]

Originally Posted by Buffymommy

Kinda sad, I too think Gina should have went farther than she did. But then again if we look back at past seasons, there has always been a shocker stay in much longer than we thought they would.

1st season-Nikki
2nd season-Josh Gracin
3rd season-Jasmine
4th season-Scott
5th season-Kevin

I am not worried anymore.

Josh Gracin puts on a great show. I've seen him in Nashville a couple of times.

[Seattleallstar]

hey caj, nice pic, whos the lucky guys givin ya a smooch on the cheek.

I didnt get to watch IDOL I fell asleep watching 16 blocks

[Buffymommy]

Originally Posted by Cajungator26

Josh Gracin puts on a great show. I've seen him in Nashville a couple of times.

I like Josh. Don't get me wrong, but at the time he was not expected to last as long as he did.

[Buffymommy]

Bye Bye Gina....

[GPK]

is this damn show on every night???? My God....

[Cajungator26]

Originally Posted by GPK

is this damn show on every night???? My God....

LMFAO

[GPK]

Originally Posted by Cajungator26

LMFAO

BDub called me earlier...and he starts on about this damn show....is there no end????

[somerfrost]

Well, I predicted the bottom three (hedged between Gina and Chris) but I was surprised that Gina left. When they sent Phil back, I was sure Haley was a goner...two weeks in a row she's in the last two. The top three were Melinda, Jordin and LaKisha...no argument. Sanjaya in the middle three...that gives us an idea where he will end up I think. Gina is better than all the boys...sad that she leaves...so far they are voting off equal numbers of boys/girls...certainly not voting on talent!

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

Well, I predicted the bottom three (hedged between Gina and Chris) but I was surprised that Gina left. When they sent Phil back, I was sure Haley was a goner...two weeks in a row she's in the last two. The top three were Melinda, Jordin and LaKisha...no argument. Sanjaya in the middle three...that gives us an idea where he will end up I think. Gina is better than all the boys...sad that she leaves...so far they are voting off equal numbers of boys/girls...certainly not voting on talent!

Bullshit. I am shocked. She was not going to win, but for Haley and Phil and Sanjaya, and quite possible even Chris R. to remain in the competition after her is awful.

We've been sitting here saying that we are confident that she will have a CD out soon though and it will do well. She's talented and she's got a personality. Good things in store for her.