5/6 ATR: McGaughey, Pletcher, Amoss, Byrne, more..

[freddymo]

Can we get a quick inquiry on PoE and why the decision to scratch when he has won on yielding ground please?

[Dahoss]

Originally Posted by freddymo

Can we get a quick inquiry on PoE and why the decision to scratch when he has won on yielding ground please?

I think I read something about him slipping a lot in the Turf classic, (that he won) so even though he won, he had a hard time on it.

Funny how no one is bringing up that Marketing Mix got scratched a few hours earlier for the same thing. Her connections didn't want her running on the course the way it was. Just like Shug and she has won over a wet course as well.

These turf courses aren't all the same, so while they both might be soft or yielding, they could be a lot different.

[NTamm1215]

Originally Posted by Dahoss

I think I read something about him slipping a lot in the Turf classic, (that he won) so even though he won, he had a hard time on it.

Funny how no one is bringing up that Marketing Mix got scratched a few hours earlier for the same thing. Her connections didn't want her running on the course the way it was. Just like Shug and she has won over a wet course as well.

These turf courses aren't all the same, so while they both might be soft or yielding, they could be a lot different.

Or that her owner tweeted immediately after the race: "We would have won."

I'm sure Dinny Phipps doesn't have a Twitter account, but I'll check to see if he had a similar feeling after the Woodford Reserve.

[Scav]

Originally Posted by Dahoss

I think I read something about him slipping a lot in the Turf classic, (that he won) so even though he won, he had a hard time on it.

Funny how no one is bringing up that Marketing Mix got scratched a few hours earlier for the same thing. Her connections didn't want her running on the course the way it was. Just like Shug and she has won over a wet course as well.

These turf courses aren't all the same, so while they both might be soft or yielding, they could be a lot different.

Yesterday morning I was bitching to our trainer about him being scratched and how he won over that type of turf surface, his next response was "Sure he won over it but how do you know how he came out of it"

So yes, I feel like an ass cause I probably didn't think it through clearly or the other side of the coin

[Kasept]

Originally Posted by freddymo

Can we get a quick inquiry on PoE and why the decision to scratch when he has won on yielding ground please?

McGaughey addresses the situation and the timeline to the decision in the second half of his visit today.

Derby & Orb connection acknowledgements by Shug runs 9:40-9:57.

Hymm Book, Tokyo Time, Hungry Island, Point of Entry and Preakness talk 10:00-10:15.

ARCHIVE: http://www.thoroughbredracingradione...y=06&Itemid=35

[freddymo]

Originally Posted by Kasept

McGaughey addresses the situation and the timeline to the decision in the second half of his visit today.

Derby & Orb connection acknowledgements by Shug runs 9:40-9:57.

Hymm Book, Tokyo Time, Hungry Island, Point of Entry and Preakness talk 10:00-10:15.

ARCHIVE: http://www.thoroughbredracingradione...y=06&Itemid=35

Geez Shug gave you the kitchen sink... I couldnt be happier for you both

[Calzone Lord]

Shug comes off as easy to like as they get.

In one of his TV interviews, he said didn't want to run Orb in the Fountain of Youth, but only ran in that spot because an allowance race for him wouldn't fill "anywhere in the area" ... which that wording sure sounded like he would have even preferred running Orb in an N2X allowance at Tampa rather than the Fountain of Youth. Payson Park is about 3 hours from Tampa.

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by Calzone Lord

Shug comes off as easy to like as they get.

In one of his TV interviews, he said didn't want to run Orb in the Fountain of Youth, but only ran in that spot because an allowance race for him wouldn't fill "anywhere in the area" ... which that wording sure sounded like he would have even preferred running Orb in an N2X allowance at Tampa rather than the Fountain of Youth. Payson Park is about 3 hours from Tampa.

He also said he would have run him in NY vs older horses, but it never filled.

[Kasept]

Originally Posted by freddymo

Geez Shug gave you the kitchen sink... I couldnt be happier for you both

Thanks Freddy. I do think he's been the trainer I've had on the show the most these past 7 years. It was a real honor for me to have the opportunity for that conversation today.