Who was closer to the Triple Crown...Smarty or Alex?

[Pointg5]

Originally Posted by Buffymommy

OK, for starters: DA HOSS WAS AN AWESOME RACE HORSE REPENT. GO WATCH HIS 2ND BC WIN. You shouldn't say things like that.

As for the topic of this thread: I would have to give the nod to Alex. I like both horses. I really do. I liked Smarty's story and the horse himself. You all blame RH10 and Eddington for the loss of his triple crown. One thing I bring up in defense of Alex: Scrappy T.

It really is silly to debate this topic. It really comes down to people's opinions on who impressed them more as a racer. Both horses were awesome and they had a great triple crown run. Lets leave it at that and not bash each other.

Not sure what Scrappy T has to do with AA losing the Triple Crown, he didn't run in the Derby and despite the bad trip AA beat him in the Preakness....


I would think RHT and Eddington are better horses than Scrappy T...

In my opinion Smarty was a better horse, but there's no arguing this with Repent. Why can't he just take this hatred to a horse that deserves it like Bernardini...