Best Player in the NFL....

[clyde]

Originally Posted by Nascar1966

Sorry I forgot to remind you about the pigs being the only six time Super Bowl winning franchise in the history of the NFL. Have the Brownies ever made it to the Super Bowl. I dont even know if they ever made it to the conference championship game. If they did was it when Brian Sipe was the QB. From what I have seen and heard so far I think McCoy has a bright future in the NFL. Im hoping he gets to play for a better team some day. I guess you dont think 28-10 is a sh t kicking. Stats dont matter, only the score matters. Cribbs could of contributed to four touchdowns but if the score was 31-28 in favor of the pigs, then who give a sh t about stats. Stats are more of a personal thing. Unfortunately all that some players care about are thier own stats and not about the team winning.

Just for your historical noodle...they got there 3 times ...the AFC.

Sipe wasn't the qb in any of them.....none.

[clyde]

I can't believe this colossal fool is bragging about beating Cleveland with a raw rookie qb....and other key players out.



This can't be happening.

[ateamstupid]

Originally Posted by clyde

I can't believe this colossal fool is bragging about beating Cleveland with a raw rookie qb....and other key players out.



This can't be happening.

WOOOOOOOOOOOSIXBURGHWOOOOOOOOOOOOOONEFORTHED!CKWOO OOOOO

They're unbearable.

[clyde]

Originally Posted by ateamstupid

WOOOOOOOOOOOSIXBURGHWOOOOOOOOOOOOOONEFORTHED!CKWOO OOOOO

They're unbearable.

It's their utter stupidity which makes them that way.



Utter, irrefutable,irrevocable,unequivocal and consummate stupidity.

[Nascar1966]

Originally Posted by clyde

It's their utter stupidity which makes them that way.



Utter, irrefutable,irrevocable,unequivocal and consummate stupidity.

Obviously we have different views on what criteria makes a player great. You and utter stupidity go hand in hand. Cribbs while not a great player isnt no slouch either. He still hasnt had a winning season, won a playoff game or yet alone a Super Bowl. Seems like you feel stats make a player great vice winning playoff games or a Super Bowl. Maybe he has had a winning season with Cleveland but he definitely hasnt won a playoff game or Super Bowl.

[Danzig]

a player can be a great one, consistently, without a playoff or superbowl ring. it is a team sport, with a great many other players helping to make or break the team. take the colts opener for instance, peyton looked awesome, and his stats looked like a winning qb's stats-but they lost the game.

[SCUDSBROTHER]

Originally Posted by Danzig

a player can be a great one, consistently, without a playoff or superbowl ring. it is a team sport, with a great many other players helping to make or break the team. take the colts opener for instance, peyton looked awesome, and his stats looked like a winning qb's stats-but they lost the game.

PEYTON consistently puts that team on his back, and carries it. He's great. He's got his ring. Peyton, Montana, and Elway were far better than that choker Marino.

[Nascar1966]

Originally Posted by Danzig

a player can be a great one, consistently, without a playoff or superbowl ring. it is a team sport, with a great many other players helping to make or break the team. take the colts opener for instance, peyton looked awesome, and his stats looked like a winning qb's stats-but they lost the game.

I agree with Peyton being a great player. He has a ring, won playoff games, and has had numerous winning seasons already.

[Crown@club]

Originally Posted by Nascar1966

Obviously we have different views on what criteria makes a player great. You and utter stupidity go hand in hand. Cribbs while not a great player isnt no slouch either. He still hasnt had a winning season, won a playoff game or yet alone a Super Bowl. Seems like you feel stats make a player great vice winning playoff games or a Super Bowl. Maybe he has had a winning season with Cleveland but he definitely hasnt won a playoff game or Super Bowl.

So by this reasoning....

Jim "pig nose" Plunkett
Jeff Hostetler
Trent Dilfer
Brad Johnson
Mark Rypien
Doug Williams
and countless others

.............are great football players.

[SCUDSBROTHER]

Originally Posted by Crown@club

So by this reasoning....

Jim "pig nose" Plunkett
Jeff Hostetler
Trent Dilfer
Brad Johnson
Mark Rypien
Doug Williams
and countless others

.............are great football players.

They aren't great, but, to be great, you better do something that even these guys got done. Again, this is about modern-era guys. If someone goes to the post 10 times, and loses the only Superbowl he got his team to, then, he wasn't great.

[Nascar1966]

Originally Posted by Crown@club

So by this reasoning....

Jim "pig nose" Plunkett
Jeff Hostetler
Trent Dilfer
Brad Johnson
Mark Rypien
Doug Williams
and countless others

.............are great football players.

I never said the above were great players. All im saying to be conseidered to maybe being a great player they should have winning seasons, playoff wins, and a Super Bowl ring.

[clyde]

Originally Posted by Nascar1966

Obviously we have different views on what criteria makes a player great. You and utter stupidity go hand in hand. Cribbs while not a great player isnt no slouch either. He still hasnt had a winning season, won a playoff game or yet alone a Super Bowl. Seems like you feel stats make a player great vice winning playoff games or a Super Bowl. Maybe he has had a winning season with Cleveland but he definitely hasnt won a playoff game or Super Bowl.

fucl< you and fucl< your rub-a-dub,too

[Nascar1966]

Originally Posted by clyde

fucl< you and fucl< your rub-a-dub,too

Love your level of maturity. Im not going to lower myself to your level. Im going to go and get ready for work. You can crawl back into your crib.

[RockHardTen1985]

I know Colts fans who take Brady 10/10 times over Manning.