Secretariat, Big Brown and Man O'War

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by ELA

The fact that I know you, should really preclude me from laughing when I read some of your posts -- but it doesn't. LOL.

Eric

Reading some of this drivel reminds me of the night at Siro's when that guy invited himself to our table.

[ELA]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

Reading some of this drivel reminds me of the night at Siro's when that guy invited himself to our table.

Umm, actually, to some extent I could see this as fun. Yes, it's always an exercise in futility to have hypothetical races between horses from different eras. Fun as it might be -- there was nothing, absolutely nothing, fun about that guy inviting himself to sit down with us. Plus, it was your table. Ironically, when he found that out, he wanted to sit there even more. LOL.

Eric

[letswastemoney]

Funny Cide would crush them all!! Especially the 7 year old version of him.

[Zaf]

Originally Posted by letswastemoney

Funny Cide would crush them all!! Especially the 7 year old version of him.

The Gutsy Gelding is Da Bomb !

[Indian Charlie]

C'mon guys, be serious!!

It's not like I threw Giant's Causeway into the mix!

[letswastemoney]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

C'mon guys, be serious!!

It's not like I threw Giant's Causeway into the mix!

I'll be serious. Man O War and Big Brown will speed duel into 21 44 fractions, setting it up for Secretariat.

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by letswastemoney

I'll be serious. Man O War and Big Brown will speed duel into 21 44 fractions, setting it up for Secretariat.

On synthetic?

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

C'mon guys, be serious!!

It's not like I threw Giant's Causeway into the mix!

he would destroy big brown on any surface, at any distance, before ppl say things about me, does anyone really disagree with that ? ?

[Thunder Gulch]

I don't know who would win a matchup of all time greats, but Perfect Drift would finish second.

[Antitrust32]

Originally Posted by hrfan

he would destroy big brown on any surface, at any distance, before ppl say things about me, does anyone really disagree with that ? ?

nope, gotta agree with ya there.

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by DaHoss9698

This is a fun thread and all, but I have a real hard time taking it seriously without Casino Drive as one of the choices.

I'm not sure he would win....but I know he would be favored.

[Zaf]

he must still eligble for some non winners what ever So Cal 4 hoss field non bettable race. Thank God for NY racing !