Commentator

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by jcs11204

i dont get it ? the numbers say he is one of the fastest horses ever ?
he defeated a champion going 1 1/8, what is the problem ?

First of all, it's bad enough you are posting at all, but repeating your posts should be a criminal offense. Secondly, why are you quoting a response I made to another poster as though I am speaking to you ( try to answer only once )?

The problem with Commentator has never been his talent.....the problem ( duh ) is keeping him sound. He is a 7YO, who has made 17 starts in what is now his 5th year of racing, so just hold your horses before you start planning too ambitious a campaign for him. First and foremost, hope he stays sound, and then perhaps, just perhaps, he will get a chance to run up to his true ability....wherever he runs.

[jcs11204]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

First of all, it's bad enough you are posting at all, but repeating your posts should be a criminal offense. Secondly, why are you quoting a response I made to another poster as though I am speaking to you ( try to answer only once )?

The problem with Commentator has never been his talent.....the problem ( duh ) is keeping him sound. He is a 7YO, who has made 17 starts in what is now his 5th year of racing, so just hold your horses before you start planning too ambitious a campaign for him. First and foremost, hope he stays sound, and then perhaps, just perhaps, he will get a chance to run up to his true ability....wherever he runs.

who is better then him right now in america ? please answer that, anywhere from 7 furlongs to 1 1/8, who is better ?

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by jcs11204

who is better then him right now in america ? please answer that, anywhere from 7 furlongs to 1 1/8, who is better ?

He doesn't have a bigger fan than me, but unlike you, the guy who told us Buffalo Man and Giant Moon couldn't lose today, I don't make outlandish claims about him. He's a wonderful racehorse. That's enough for me.

There are many very talented horses who for a variety of reasons don't get a chance to show it.

[jcs11204]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

He doesn't have a bigger fan than me, but unlike you, the guy who told us Buffalo Man and Giant Moon couldn't lose today, I don't make outlandish claims about him. He's a wonderful racehorse. That's enough for me.

There are many very talented horses who for a variety of reasons don't get a chance to show it.

i loved buffalo man and giant moon, and lost money on both of them.
i am not affraid to voice my opinion

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by jcs11204

i loved buffalo man and giant moon, and lost money on both of them.
i am not affraid to voice my opinion

No you're not.

Unfortunately.

[hoovesupsideyourhead]

the rose famliy stable on big stakes days comes though again........

and congrats to nick ..and his staff..great job......

[jcs11204]

commentator would beat curlin at 1 1/8

[jcs11204]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

He doesn't have a bigger fan than me, but unlike you, the guy who told us Buffalo Man and Giant Moon couldn't lose today, I don't make outlandish claims about him. He's a wonderful racehorse. That's enough for me.

There are many very talented horses who for a variety of reasons don't get a chance to show it.

ok i understand... where is he pointing to next ?

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by jcs11204

ok i understand... where is he pointing to next ?

The AP Smithwick.

[Danzig]

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

First of all, it's bad enough you are posting at all, but repeating your posts should be a criminal offense. Secondly, why are you quoting a response I made to another poster as though I am speaking to you ( try to answer only once )?

The problem with Commentator has never been his talent.....the problem ( duh ) is keeping him sound. He is a 7YO, who has made 17 starts in what is now his 5th year of racing, so just hold your horses before you start planning too ambitious a campaign for him. First and foremost, hope he stays sound, and then perhaps, just perhaps, he will get a chance to run up to his true ability....wherever he runs.

I hate it when horses with as much talent as this one can't stay sound. It is also hard to tell if you don't have inside information on the animal, when they are feeling their best and ready to go and win, or they put in a clunker of a race because they are hurting a bit. I have seen Commentator be absolutely brillant, and seen him have performances that would have left me scratching my head if he didn't have such a low number of starts all these years.

Glad you talked him out of sending him to Dubai. Definitely the right decision. Now, maybe he can win some more GIs in the states with proper timing and management.

[blackthroatedwind]

Can you imagine if someone actually believed me that Nick was planning on sending him to Dubai?

Thank God that didn't happen.

[kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

Can you imagine if someone actually believed me that Nick was planning on sending him to Dubai?

Thank God that didn't happen.

Sorry...excuse me...

I was trying to say good job in a round about way. It's not like I haven't seen trainers over the years make stupider moves, and I don't follow Zito that closely.

[jcs11204]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

Can you imagine if someone actually believed me that Nick was planning on sending him to Dubai?

Thank God that didn't happen.

i did not belive, knew you were trying to be funny...

BUT why not ? the mile, he would jog.... not the world cup, there might be to much other early speed, plus i am starting to love that 9 million doller monster jalil, i think that is propper spelling.

[Cannon Shell]

Thud

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Thud

This thread belongs in a new room.....the dopey room.

[Cannon Shell]

This thread should be burned or buried in a time capsule

[hoovesupsideyourhead]

[quote=kentuckyrosesinmay]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

First of all, it's bad enough you are posting at all, but repeating your posts should be a criminal offense. Secondly, why are you quoting a response I made to another poster as though I am speaking to you ( try to answer only once )?

The problem with Commentator has never been his talent.....the problem ( duh ) is keeping him sound. He is a 7YO, who has made 17 starts in what is now his 5th year of racing, so just hold your horses before you start planning too ambitious a campaign for him. First and foremost, hope he stays sound, and then perhaps, just perhaps, he will get a chance to run up to his true ability....wherever he runs.[/QUOTE]


I hate it when horses with as much talent as this one can't stay sound. It is also hard to tell if you don't have inside information on the animal, when they are feeling their best and ready to go and win, or they put in a clunker of a race because they are hurting a bit. I have seen Commentator be absolutely brillant, and seen him have performances that would have left me scratching my head if he didn't have such a low number of starts all these years.

Glad you talked him out of sending him to Dubai. Definitely the right decision. Now, maybe he can win some more GIs in the states with proper timing and management.

just so your not more confused..andy was the one who recomended commentator running in the whitney.........