How do you.....

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by Sightseek

You're a way better judge than I, but I think the performances Curlin put up in the JCGC & BCC were far superior to anything Bernardini did the year before. Lawyer Ron was pretty good in the Gold Cup too.

I think all things being equal, Bernardini's effort in the BC Classic would have given Curlin a very hard time. Plus, Bernardini's Preakness win extremely impressive.

I think the two are relative equals, and like I said, could argue either side. I rated Curlin ahead of Bernardini. It's close.