Another Confusing Decision from the NY Stewards

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Grits

Correct decisions and incorrect decisions are made each day by stewards reviewing races.

Why would it be acceptable to allow incorrect decisions to be made on a daily basis? How long would you keep your job if you made incorrect decisions on a daily basis? Think about how you would feel if you got taken down in the last leg of a big carryover pick 6 because the stewards made an incorrect decision and they took half a million dollars out of your pocket?

[Merlinsky]

I realize some folks like their jockeys as aggressive as possible figuring they can force a win by sheer force of jerkdom. Well as far as Coa's behavior if I were the owner of the horse he rode I wouldn't care that he got up to 3rd. I'd demand he be dropped and if he got mad I'd let him know I don't appreciate 2 men engaging in 1200 lb p*ssing contests when my animal's involved. Horses are in a precarious situation anytime they run anywhere. How does he know someone might not fall or strain something? Put a foot down awkwardly? There's acceptable risk and there's the jockey causing a problem. This isn't pushing a horse to win a head bob, it's road rage on horseback.

Losing enough mounts from owners expressing displeasure would sure have an impact if stewards refused to do their jobs properly wouldn't it? If you as an owner got smoke blown up your butt about it and yelled 'I don't care who started it, you don't pull that crap on my horse!' at least maybe their agent will tell em if they don't knock it off he can't get them work. And not just for a 30 day suspension either. You'd be the elephant that didn't forget unless he proved he was willing to cut it out.

[Grits]

Incorrect decisions are and will continue to be made as long as horses are running year-round on the North American continent.

Do I find it acceptable, no can't say that I do. Do I find it probable, yes, due to the number of races run and human error being fallible. Baseball umpires make errors-bad calls, as do other referees in sports. The difference being, their calls can be challenged. Stewards, rarely are.

As far as your pick 6 question, I know it is heartbreaking, as a friend had the only live ticket late one afternoon in Saratoga, wherein he would've taken down the entire pool, but for the fact that his final selection was dqed by the stewards.

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Why would it be acceptable to allow incorrect decisions to be made on a daily basis? How long would you keep your job if you made incorrect decisions on a daily basis? Think about how you would feel if you got taken down in the last leg of a big carryover pick 6 because the stewards made an incorrect decision and they took half a million dollars out of your pocket?

[whodey17]

Stewards have a hard job. For the most part, I think they do a fine job at race tracks all over the USA.

[Left Bank]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Why would it be acceptable to allow incorrect decisions to be made on a daily basis? How long would you keep your job if you made incorrect decisions on a daily basis? Think about how you would feel if you got taken down in the last leg of a big carryover pick 6 because the stewards made an incorrect decision and they took half a million dollars out of your pocket?

Weathermen make incorrect decisions and predictions daily.

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Kimmeastar

Weathermen make incorrect decisions and predictions daily.

And as such are one of the least respected professions in the world. But if they were called in to analyze the weather after it occurred, I bet most of them would be pretty accurate. Unlike many stewards.

[Grits]

Wow Cannon, "least respected" . . . you're a little strong aren't you? Where I live, most of them have degrees in Metoerological Science, and they don't get too much of it wrong any more.

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

And as such are one of the least respected professions in the world. But if they were called in to analyze the weather after it occurred, I bet most of them would be pretty accurate. Unlike many stewards.

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Grits

Wow Cannon, "least respected" . . . you're a little strong aren't you? Where I live, most of them have degrees in Metoerological Science, and they don't get too much of it wrong any more.

No. Computers do most of their work now anyway, and they are still wrong quite often. Name a lesser respected professional profession? Politicians dont count!

[MisterB]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

No. Computers do most of their work now anyway, and they are still wrong quite often. Name a lesser respected professional profession? Politicians dont count!

The American War fighter!!

Under paid too

[Grits]

Looks like I may be searching for another trainer, if and when I buy a horse.
I don't think this one cares for me one iota.
And knowing he's good.

Bummer.

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

No. Computers do most of their work now anyway, and they are still wrong quite often. Name a lesser respected professional profession? Politicians dont count!

[ninetoone]

I'm a little late to chime in on this thread, but I thought that Coa displayed a questionable move on Saturday as well. I believe it was the 4th race...he ended up winning, but pinched the 2nd place horse tight on the rail in deep stretch, causing him to check (Ponce aboard). I remember thinking it was unnecessary at the time.

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Grits

Looks like I may be searching for another trainer, if and when I buy a horse.
I don't think this one cares for me one iota.
And knowing he's good.

Bummer.

yikes...my husband and i disagree on some things--not looking for a new hubby! just because someone disagrees with you on something doesn't mean anything personal.

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Grits

Looks like I may be searching for another trainer, if and when I buy a horse.
I don't think this one cares for me one iota.
And knowing he's good.

Bummer.

What do you work for the weather channel or something?

[Payson Dave]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

No. Computers do most of their work now anyway, and they are still wrong quite often. Name a lesser respected professional profession? Politicians dont count!

Maybe Lawyers...

[Payson Dave]

Are not the NY stewards basically political appointees???

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Payson Dave

Maybe Lawyers...

You respect them when you need them!