Hall of Fame? Yes or No

[somerfrost]

[quote=Cannon Shell]Assuming they finish as expected.

Ichiro...absolute lock

Vlad Guerrero...yes

Jim Thome...no

John Smoltz...yes

Johnny Damon...no

Trevor Hoffman...yes

Todd Helton...no

Chipper Jones...maybe

Bobby Abreu...no

Gary Sheffield...no

Miguel Tejada...no

Andy Pettite...possibly


Amazed that Ichiro isn't 100%, leaving him out of the Hall would be the biggest crime since Pete Rose!