Barbaro (the Champ)

Originally Posted by King Glorious

I'd like u to tell me one horse that won HOY but wasn't even named champion in his own division.

It could happen this year, King ... if ...

... if ... as rumored ... they count "Get Well" cards as votes in the 3YO balloting ... but disallow them in the HOTY voting ...

... the awards could be split.

Other than that ... you're right ... it's never happened.