American Idol Round of 4: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[ArlJim78]

Love the Bee Gees but it didn't help most of them in my view.

Blake I have to say was pretty bad, like Randy said, dude we know you can do the beat box thing but you don't have to do it every song.

Lakisha ho -hum

Melinda- no noticeable flaws but nothing earth shaking either.

Jordin, well the first song didn't do much for me, but her second song I thought was just terrific. I didn't watch her but just listened to it. It was at that point I said that this girl is the top talent on here, and should win in a close decision over Melinda.