Quote:
Originally Posted by NTamm1215
These are his updated PPs after yesterday. If you're arguing that he didn't move too early, you're wrong.
 |
I don't see how this negates Port Conway Lane's argument; namely that Normandy Invasion's "early move" was more a case of other horses backing up than Normandy Invasion making a move.
Looking at the splits posted by Port Conway Lane, that argument makes sense to me. Is there an error in PCL's splits?
If the splits are correct, then NI's 3rd quarter mile, 23:89, was slower than 8 other horses's. NI's 4th quarter mile, 25:48, was slower than 7 other horses's.
Also, exactly which part of Cannon Shell's post was nonsense? If you are claiming that running a blistering 23:89 3rd quarter is what ruined Normandy Invasion's chances, when 8 other horses ran faster 3rd quarters including the first 3 finishers, then that makes no sense to me.
The fact that both you and cmorioles agree on this gives me pause. I just wish you'd make a clearer case for it.
--Dunbar